General Solution of a Poisson Equation (maybe difficult)

In summary, the conversation discusses the differences between Laplace and Poisson equations and their use in physics. The general solution to the Poisson equation is a combination of a particular solution and a homogenous part, which includes fundamental solutions to the Laplace equation. However, the specific values and equations used in this problem may require further study in potential theory to fully understand.
  • #1
tim9000
867
17
Hi,
This is overwhelmingly more of a maths problem than a physics problem, because it's all theoretical. I'll give some background to modle it incase the math's isn't enough.
Say you've got a planar structure of thickness 'd', lying on the z plane. Also say the upper and lower surfaces are y = 0 and y = -d, respectively.
The structure has scalar potentials inside it as so:
upload_2015-4-5_20-41-8.png

As you can see the vector fields cancel out on one side, As it says below, there is a Poisson equation of:
upload_2015-4-5_20-42-39.png

BUT I HAVE NO IDEA WHY that is the poission equation, I get that Fiinside is a scalar potential, but why is mok.cos(kx) the vector field?, not like mx+my or something instead? It looks like they've just differentiated mx and that's the vector function, maybe just a coincidence?
I also have no idea how that is the general solution? Specifically the homogenious part.
I get that for the part of the particular you can solve the Poisson equation of using method of undetermined coefficients with a guess of (Asin(kx) + Bcos(kx)) and just differentiate that twice for del2:
(Asin(kx) + Bcos(kx))'' = mok.Cos(kx)
therefore: -A.k2sin(kx)-Bk2cos(kx) = mok.Cos(kx)
therefore: -A.ksin(kx)-Bkcos(kx) = mo.Cos(kx) and equating coefficients yields:
B = - mo/k
A = 0
so Yp = - mo/k * Cos(kx)

But why does the homogenous part have exponentials and y in them? I thought they'd just be zero.
If someone could explain that or even just why the Poisson equation is what they say I'd be greatful.
THANKS!

P.S I also wonder, which point is chosen as x = 0 on the diagram...?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
A Laplace equation has the form:

2 φ = 0, where φ = f(x,y), which are also called harmonic functions.

A Poisson equation is just the non-homogeneous form of a Laplace equation, for example:

2 φ = g (x,y) + K, where g (x,y) is a function of x and y, and K is just a constant.

These two partial differential equations see wide use in physics, particularly mechanics, hydromechanics, electrostatics, etc.

The solution to the Laplace equation φ = 0 is a trivial one and is not particularly useful.

You could also solve many ordinary differential equations using y = 0, but there could be other, non-zero solutions. :wink:
 
  • #3
SteamKing said:
A Laplace equation has the form:

2 φ = 0, where φ = f(x,y), which are also called harmonic functions.

A Poisson equation is just the non-homogeneous form of a Laplace equation, for example:

2 φ = g (x,y) + K, where g (x,y) is a function of x and y, and K is just a constant.

These two partial differential equations see wide use in physics, particularly mechanics, hydromechanics, electrostatics, etc.

The solution to the Laplace equation φ = 0 is a trivial one and is not particularly useful.

You could also solve many ordinary differential equations using y = 0, but there could be other, non-zero solutions. :wink:
Oook, I get that, but the General solution = homogenious + particular, solutions. As you can see in (3b) the particular solution I worked out is in there, but so is the 'homogenous' aspect which I can't figure out. As you can see in (2a) the Poisson is non-homogenous (not laplace) but it must use a homogenous part in the method of undetermined coefficients, I expect, to find (3a) and (3c) as well as the afformentioned aspect of (3b).
 
Last edited:
  • #4
tim9000 said:
Oook, I get that, but the General solution = homogenious + particular, solutions. As you can see in (3b) the particular solution I worked out is in there, but so is the 'homogenous' aspect which I can't figure out. As you can see in (2a) the Poisson is non-homogenous (not laplace) but it must use a homogenous part in the method of undetermined coefficients, I expect, to find (3a) and (3c) as well as the afformentioned aspect of (3b).

There are whole classes of fundamental solutions to the Laplace equation. Selecting which fundamental solution depends on the boundary conditions of the problem under consideration. All of this is covered in the study of potential theory:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laplace's_equation

These fundamental solutions include complex analytic functions and combinations of trig and exponential functions, as seen in the OP.

Without studying the rest of your text, I think you are expected to take it on faith that the equations describing this particular problem have the solutions shown. If you should later study potential theory, then that course will go into more detail about the fundamental solutions to the Laplace equation and how they are derived.
 
  • #5
SteamKing said:
There are whole classes of fundamental solutions to the Laplace equation. Selecting which fundamental solution depends on the boundary conditions of the problem under consideration. All of this is covered in the study of potential theory:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laplace's_equation

These fundamental solutions include complex analytic functions and combinations of trig and exponential functions, as seen in the OP.

Without studying the rest of your text, I think you are expected to take it on faith that the equations describing this particular problem have the solutions shown. If you should later study potential theory, then that course will go into more detail about the fundamental solutions to the Laplace equation and how they are derived.
The boundary conditions are given later so I didn't think they were used to find the general solution. It would seem weird that I can find half of the solution and not the rest. And that doesn't explain how they came to that value of the Poisson equation.
upload_2015-4-5_22-45-46.png
 

Related to General Solution of a Poisson Equation (maybe difficult)

1. What is a Poisson Equation?

A Poisson equation is a partial differential equation that describes the distribution of a scalar quantity (such as temperature, pressure, or electric potential) in a given region, based on the sources and boundaries of that quantity.

2. What is the significance of a General Solution in the context of a Poisson Equation?

A general solution of a Poisson equation is a mathematical representation that satisfies the equation and can be used to find specific solutions for different boundary conditions. It allows for a more efficient and systematic approach to solving the equation for different scenarios.

3. How is the General Solution of a Poisson Equation obtained?

The general solution of a Poisson equation is obtained by solving the equation using various mathematical techniques, such as separation of variables, Green's function, or finite difference methods. The specific method used depends on the complexity of the equation and the boundary conditions.

4. What are the challenges in finding a General Solution of a Poisson Equation?

The difficulty in finding a general solution of a Poisson equation lies in the complexity of the equation and the need to satisfy specific boundary conditions. It requires a deep understanding of mathematical techniques and the ability to apply them effectively to solve the equation.

5. How is the General Solution of a Poisson Equation used in real-world applications?

The general solution of a Poisson equation has many applications in physics, engineering, and other fields. It can be used to model and predict the behavior of various physical phenomena, such as heat flow, fluid dynamics, and electrostatics. It is also used in the development of numerical methods for solving more complex equations in these fields.

Similar threads

  • Differential Equations
2
Replies
52
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • Differential Equations
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • Linear and Abstract Algebra
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Differential Equations
Replies
1
Views
891
  • General Math
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top