Entries by ZapperZ

Addressing the “Classical Physics Is Wrong” Fallacy

One of the common questions or comments we get on PF is the claim that classical physics or classical mechanics (i.e. Newton’s laws, etc.) is wrong because it has been superseded by Special Relativity (SR) and General Relativity (GR), and/or Quantum Mechanics (QM). Such claims are typically made by either a student who barely learned…

How to Ask Questions Effectively and Avoid Cold Questions

We frequently get questions such as these: “What is energy?” “What are Cooper Pairs?” “What is conservation of momentum?” etc…etc. And the persons who asked such questions didn’t bother to explain the context of the question, what exactly did he/she wanted to know, and didn’t reveal the level of education that he/she could understand. While…

The Problem of Fake News and Science Reporting

During and even after the recent US election campaign, numerous reports of fake news, made-up news, and other kinds of news were deemed either outright fabrication or inaccurate or incomplete reporting of something to skewer it into one point of view or another. While the outright fabricated news can easily be spotted eventually, other kinds…

Why Is Quantum Mechanics So Difficult?

Quantum Mechanics Key points: Quantum mechanics (QM) is often perceived as difficult, especially by non-physicists. The difficulty lies in the conceptual foundation of QM, as it doesn’t connect well with classical understanding. Unlike other areas of physics, there’s no direct continuity between classical concepts and QM. While the conceptual understanding is challenging, the mathematical formulation…

So I Am Your Intro Physics Instructor

I posted this elsewhere (on my blog), and someone mentioned that maybe it might also be useful here on PF. So I’m reproducing the entire entry here in case it might make a difference. This is essentially a “sequel” to my earlier essay on “So I am Your Academic Advisor“. My aim in writing this…

Have Scientists Seen an Electron?

This is not about seeing an electron, but rather, the notion that seeing something with our eyes is the end-all requirement for the validity of anything. I will show that our human eye, as a light detector, is NOT a very good detector in many aspects, and thus, using it as the standard detector to…

Do Photons Move Slower in a Solid Medium?

This question appears often because it has been shown that in a normal, dispersive solid such as glass, the speed of light is slower than it is in a vacuum. This FAQ will strictly deal with that scenario only and will not address light transport in anomalous medium, atomic vapor, metals, etc., and will only…

Why Is Acceleration Due to Gravity a Constant?

This question has popped up many times. So here is an attempt to address it. To answer this question at the elementary level, several assumptions will be made, which will become obvious later on. Still, at this point, we will simply deal with objects with spherical symmetry and no complicated mass distribution. In other words,…

“Violating” Einstein’s Photoelectric Effect Model

One of the most spectacular theoretical descriptions that Einstein had ever produced is the corpuscular nature of light that he used in his 1905 photoelectric effect paper. In fact, there have been arguments put forth that of all of his 1905 papers, the one proposing this model for light is what is truly most revolutionary,…

Do Photons have Mass?

Do photons have mass? The quick answer: NO However, this is where it gets a bit confusing for most people. This is because, in physics, there are several ways to define and measure a quantity that we call “mass”. Now, it doesn’t create any confusion among physicists because we tend to know in what context…

Why You Can’t Quantum Tunnel Through a Wall

What is quantum tunneling? Quantum tunneling is a phenomenon in quantum mechanics where particles exhibit the ability to pass through energy barriers that would be insurmountable in classical physics. It occurs when particles, such as electrons, exhibit wave-like behavior and are described by the principles of quantum mechanics. Quantum tunneling challenges our classical intuition and…

Your Curriculum Vitae As a Physics Graduate

    I am going to backtrack a little bit and talk about writing your Curriculum Vitae (CV) and what you should focus on in search of a job in physics. This includes looking for a Postdoctoral position, a research position, and possibly a faculty position at a university. I am going to base this…

How to Get a Postdoctoral Physics Position

    If you intend to pursue an academic/research career, chances are, you will need postdoctoral experience. This is typically a 2 to 3-year appointment either at a university, national laboratories, or industrial laboratories such as Bell Lab. It is not uncommon for someone to do 2 postdoctoral positions before finding suitable employment. So this…

How to Get a Physics Job

    In the previous chapter, we have reached the point where you have finished with your thesis defense, and also thesis submission to the graduate school. You are all set to go into the nasty physics world and look for a job. If that is your case, then you are SCREWED! You do NOT…

Your Physics Thesis Defense Guide

    At this point, you have completed writing your thesis, your adviser has approved it, and you have distributed it to all the members of your thesis committee. It is now time for you to do your thesis defense. Officially, this is the final obstacle standing in the way between you and your Ph.D….

Oral Presentations – Addendum | Physics Career

I’ll try not to make a habit out of this, but I believe there’s something to add to this chapter of the series. In Part XIV, I mentioned the APS Meetings – March and April – which typically tend to be the largest yearly gathering of physicists. They both covered different areas of physics, i.e….

How to Publish in a Physics Journal (Addendum)

  When I first wrote this part of the series, I wasn’t quite sure if I should include this. for most people submitting to most of the physics journals, this isn’t an issue. But considering the number of very bright students, we have on here, inevitably some of you might consider submitting a manuscript to…

How to Succeed at Oral Presentations As a Physics Major

    I mentioned earlier that there are two ways for physicists to communicate their work. The first is via publications in peer-reviewed journals. I have covered this in the last chapter of this series. The second, which we will cover here, is through oral presentations at various scientific conferences. Each year, there are scientific…

Alternative Careers for a Physics Graduate

    We are still discussing the final year of your undergraduate education. So far, we have covered what you need to consider if you want to go on to graduate school and prepare yourself as best as you can for that part of your journey. This is the “traditional” path that many physics students…

How to Apply for Physics Graduate School

  We have now reached the final year of your undergraduate program. By now, you would have gone through courses in the fundamental pillars of physics (Classical mechanics, Quantum mechanics, and E&M), and even courses in Thermodynamics/Statistical Physics. Academically, this is where you start taking more advanced courses, even some graduate-level courses. There are plenty…

Explaining the Life of a Physics Major

  So far, I have covered what I believe a student needs to the end of the 2nd year of studies. In most schools in the US, an undergraduate must have a declared major by the end of the 2nd year (if not sooner). So by now, you should already be officially a physics major….

Mathematical Preparations For a Physics Major

  Part III: Mathematical Preparations In most universities in the US, a student must have a declared major by the end of his or her second year. So this is an important transition – committing in a particular area of study. By now, if you have followed the first two chapters of this series, you…