A difficult and tricky problem

  • Thread starter agnibho
  • Start date
In summary, the problem states that there are 15 coins, with 5 showing heads and 10 showing tails. The task is to divide the coins into two groups, each with an equal number of heads but without overturning any coins. Though it may seem impossible, there is a solution involving arranging the coins on edge. The concept of being blindfolded does not seem to be relevant to the solution.
  • #1
agnibho
46
0

Homework Statement


You've 15 coins out of which 5 coins are turned with their HEAD facing upwards and the rest 10 have their TAILS facing upwards. Suppose you have been blindfolded. Now you've got to divide these 15 coins in two groups such that each group has the same number of coins have their HEADs facing up. But you cannot overturn any coin. How can you do it?? It may seem practically impossible but it can be really done!
2. The attempt at a solution
I thought it might be a problem of probability. I found the probability of HEAD which is 1/15 i.e. 1/3 which means one out of three. But actually I think it is impossible as to the fact that the number of HEADs is odd and we can't divide it into two equal groups! But in the question it says that it can be done! I suppose there must be some trick in it. Please help me.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
agnibho said:

Homework Statement


You've 15 coins out of which 5 coins are turned with their HEAD facing upwards and the rest 15 have their TAILS facing upwards. Suppose you have been blindfolded. Now you've got to divide these 15 coins in two groups such that each group has the same number of coins have their HEADs facing up. But you cannot overturn any coin. How can you do it?? It may seem practically impossible but it can be really done!
2. The attempt at a solution
I thought it might be a problem of probability. I found the probability of HEAD which is 1/15 i.e. 1/3 which means one out of three. But actually I think it is impossible as to the fact that the number of HEADs is odd and we can't divide it into two equal groups! But in the question it says that it can be done! I suppose there must be some trick in it. Please help me.

Sorry to say but one difficulty is that if there is a trick in the question, it could easily be hidden in the less than perfect English used to supply the information here.

Perhaps you divide the coins into two groups, of any size you like, but arrange the coins on edge, to form a couple of "cylinders". That way you have not overturned and coin, just stood all of them on edge??
 
Last edited:
  • #3
Suppose you have been blindfolded.

I can't see why it is specified that you be blindfolded.

15 coins? So maybe you cover over one of the heads with a tails-up coin?
 

FAQ: A difficult and tricky problem

What is the best way to approach a difficult and tricky problem?

The best way to approach a difficult and tricky problem is to break it down into smaller, manageable parts. This will help you to better understand the problem and find potential solutions.

How can I overcome the feeling of being overwhelmed when facing a difficult and tricky problem?

One way to overcome the feeling of being overwhelmed is to take a step back and look at the problem from a different perspective. This can help to provide new insights and potential solutions.

How can I stay motivated while working on a difficult and tricky problem?

It can be helpful to set small, achievable goals and celebrate each milestone. Additionally, taking breaks and engaging in activities outside of the problem can help to maintain motivation.

Are there any techniques that can help with problem-solving for a difficult and tricky problem?

Yes, there are various problem-solving techniques such as brainstorming, mind mapping, and trial and error. It can also be beneficial to collaborate with others and gather different perspectives.

What should I do if I am unable to find a solution to a difficult and tricky problem?

If you are unable to find a solution, it may be helpful to seek advice or assistance from others. Sometimes, a fresh perspective or a different approach can lead to a breakthrough. Don't be afraid to ask for help when needed.

Back
Top