Are Differential Distances Along Curved Surfaces Larger Than Fixed Distances?

In summary, the conversation discusses using polar coordinates to simplify a problem involving electron constraint on a hoop. This allows for a more straightforward calculation of the loop's length using the old Schrödinger-equation. Additionally, the conversation mentions the limit formula that shows the relationship between the length of a chord and the corresponding arc when they are small.
  • #1
aaaa202
1,169
2
I recently did a problem with some electron constraint to move on a hoop. It kind of surprised me that you just could take the old Schrödinger-equation with and let your
dx ->dβ, where β is the distance along the hoop.
Saying it in a less mathematical way, isn't a differential distance along something curved larger than a differential distance in a fixed direction? I do realize that a rigorous mathematician would shoot me for saying something like this, so how would he say it?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
In a problem like this the best suited thing to do is to pass to polar coordinates, so you can describe a loop more simply. Then in these coordinates with origin at the center of the loop which is at a fixed radius r, you have [itex]dx^2+dy^2=r^2d\theta^2=d\beta^2[/itex]. So it's simply the old good polar coordinates.
 
  • #3
Remember this? ## \displaystyle \lim_{x \rightarrow 0 } \frac {\sin x} {x} = 1 ##.

It ensures that the length of a chord and the corresponding arc are about the same when they are small, let alone differential. It might be useful for you to follow the proof of the statement.
 

FAQ: Are Differential Distances Along Curved Surfaces Larger Than Fixed Distances?

What is the purpose of comparing differentials?

The purpose of comparing differentials is to analyze the rates of change of two or more related variables and understand how they are related to each other. This can help in making predictions, identifying patterns, and drawing conclusions about the behavior of the variables.

How do you calculate differentials?

Differentials can be calculated by subtracting the final value of the variable from its initial value and dividing it by the change in the independent variable. This is represented as Δy/Δx, where Δy is the change in the dependent variable and Δx is the change in the independent variable.

What is the difference between absolute and relative differentials?

The absolute differential is the actual change in the dependent variable, while the relative differential is the percentage change in the dependent variable with respect to the initial value. For example, if the absolute differential is 5 and the initial value is 10, the relative differential would be 50%.

Can differentials be negative?

Yes, differentials can be negative. A negative differential indicates a decrease in the dependent variable, while a positive differential indicates an increase. It is important to pay attention to the sign of the differential when comparing variables.

In what situations is comparing differentials useful?

Comparing differentials is useful in situations where there are multiple variables that may affect each other, and understanding their relationship and rates of change is important. This can be applied in various fields such as economics, physics, and biology, to name a few.

Back
Top