Can't Solve the Relativity Problem: Seeking Help

  • Thread starter Jilvin
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Relativity
In summary, C. Schiller's text on relativity provides an expression for the ratio of frequencies between two observers, one moving at a velocity v with respect to the other. The expression takes into account the angles at which a light signal is sent and received and is given by the equation \lambda_{r}/\lambda_{s}=\gamma(1-(v/c)cos \theta_{r}). This can be found in section 4.2.3 of the Motion Mountain volume II text, along with a solution for problem 11 in ch. 4 for the generalization to more than one spatial dimensions using four-vectors. For those unfamiliar with four-vectors, there are alternative methods but they may be more complicated.
  • #1
Jilvin
18
0
I was reading C. Schiller's text on relativity and he gives an expression for the ratio frequencies of two observers (one a sender and one a receiver). *[Oh, and if you think that my description of the problem is unclear, I am talking about the expression on page 30 of the Motion Mountain volume II text]*

Observer S is moving at a velocity v with respect to observer R, and sends a light signal at an angle [tex]\theta_{s}[/tex]. Observer R receives the signal at an angle [tex]\theta_{r}[/tex]. The expression given for the ratio of the two wavelengths is:

[tex]\lambda_{r}[/tex]/[tex]\lambda_{s}[/tex]=[tex]\gamma[/tex](1-(v/c)cos [tex]\theta_{r}[/tex])

I have tried to reproduce this assertion independently, but can't! Someone more skilled please help.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
You can find a derivation in my book:
http://www.lightandmatter.com/genrel/
See section 4.2.3 for the 1-dimensional case, and the solution in the back of the book for problem 11 in ch. 4 for the generalization to more than one spatial dimensions. This uses four-vectors. If you aren't comfortable with four-vectors, I'm sure it can be done, but it probably becomes a more cumbersome calculation.
 
  • #3
Thank you. I am slightly familiar with four-vectors but i'll need some touching up. However, I am willing to do this so this reference is satisfactory for now.

OFF TOPIC: I used you calculus book for self-study last year by the way. I only looked at it for 2 months prior to the AP Calc AB test and I managed to score a 4. So thanks for your material!
 

FAQ: Can't Solve the Relativity Problem: Seeking Help

Why is solving the relativity problem important?

Solving the relativity problem is important because it is a fundamental aspect of understanding the universe. Relativity is one of the pillars of modern physics and has revolutionized our understanding of space, time, and gravity. It also has practical applications, such as in GPS technology.

What is the relativity problem?

The relativity problem refers to the challenge of reconciling Einstein's theory of relativity with quantum mechanics. While both theories have been extensively tested and proven to be accurate, they seem to contradict each other in certain situations, such as at the level of subatomic particles.

Has anyone been able to solve the relativity problem?

No, the relativity problem remains unsolved. Many physicists have attempted to find a unified theory that combines relativity and quantum mechanics, but so far, none have been successful. It continues to be an area of ongoing research and debate in the scientific community.

Is the relativity problem the only major unsolved problem in physics?

No, there are several other major unsolved problems in physics, including the nature of dark matter and dark energy, the origin of the universe, and the unification of all fundamental forces. The relativity problem is just one of the many mysteries that scientists are still trying to unravel.

How can I help solve the relativity problem?

If you are a physicist, you can contribute to solving the relativity problem by conducting research and proposing new theories. If you are not a scientist, you can support scientific research and education, stay informed about new developments, and engage in discussions about the topic. Every contribution, big or small, can help advance our understanding of the universe.

Back
Top