Correct Method for Finding Area Between 2 Curves Using Integration

In summary, the correct method for finding the area between two curves when integrating with respect to the y-axis is to subtract the function on the left from the function on the right. This is because, when thinking about it physically, the "top curve minus bottom curve" method only works when integrating with respect to the x-axis. For integration with respect to the y-axis, the "top curve" is actually the right curve.
  • #1
masterflex
17
0

Homework Statement


The picture is found here (top picture):
http://www.iastate.edu/~statics/examples/centroid/centroida.html#ysubc



Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution


I get the wrong sign (ie: negative area) when I integrate to find the area between 2 curves when I integrate with respect to the y-axis (ie: when I use dy). So since my area is negative, I must be subtracting the wrong curve from the other curve (ie: instead of F-G, it should be G-F). Should it be [(top curve)-(bottom curve)] ? That's what I did, but it appears that [(bottom curve)-(top curve)] gives the correct answer. By the way, my work (attached pict) also shows me using dx just to prove to myself that it works, which it did. Thanks for any logic help.
 

Attachments

  • area_btw_curves.JPG
    area_btw_curves.JPG
    15 KB · Views: 440
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Think about finding the area by using a whole bunch of rectangles. Since you're integrating with respect to the y-axis, you'll have a lot of skinny rectangles oriented in the left-right direction. What's this about top/bottom then? Wouldn't you want to take the function on the right and subtract the function on the left to find the height of your rectangle?
 
  • #3
makes total sense pizza (when you think about it physically). I didn't initially interpret it physically. The "top curve minus bottom curve" to find the area between 2 curves works only for dx; that's what the teacher told us. But for dy, the "top curve" is the right curve. I can see it now.
 

FAQ: Correct Method for Finding Area Between 2 Curves Using Integration

What is the "area between 2 curves"?

The area between 2 curves refers to the region enclosed by two curves on a graph. This area can be calculated using mathematical methods such as integration.

How do you find the area between 2 curves?

To find the area between 2 curves, you can use the definite integral formula. First, find the points where the two curves intersect. Then, integrate the difference between the two curves from the lower intersection point to the higher intersection point.

Can the area between 2 curves be negative?

Yes, the area between 2 curves can be negative if the lower curve is above the higher curve in certain regions. This indicates a "negative" area, or an area that is below the x-axis on the graph.

What is the importance of calculating the area between 2 curves?

Calculating the area between 2 curves is important in many scientific and mathematical fields, such as physics, engineering, and economics. It can help determine the total amount of a substance in a certain region, the amount of work done, or the total profit or loss in a business.

Are there any limitations to finding the area between 2 curves?

Yes, there are limitations to finding the area between 2 curves. The curves must be continuous and intersect at least once in the given interval for the area to be calculated accurately. Additionally, some curves may be too complex to integrate, making it difficult to find the exact area between them.

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
13
Views
4K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
18
Views
2K
Replies
59
Views
4K
Back
Top