Helping a prof with his research vs doing your own research.

[Simfish]

So all of my research experience so far has been done with helping a prof with his research. I haven't really done any independent research on my own. Is this the norm among students who apply to grad school? Is it not as good as me doing my own research? (and compared to students who have done their own research projects, is it a significant disadvantage?) Of course I can put it in my personal statement and say that I understood what my role was and the direction the research is supposed to take (e.g. show that I'm perfectly capable of having my own research project should I have the chance to do it)

 

[eri]

It's unusual for students who haven't already spent a few years in graduate school to know enough about a topic to come up with something original to study. Grad schools will expect you to have worked with a professor, and you'll be doing that in graduate school as well. Many people finish a PhD without having come up with very original ideas of their own and working on a suggestion from a professor instead.

 

[twofish-quant]

So all of my research experience so far has been done with helping a prof with his research. I haven't really done any independent research on my own.

Yes. It's normal. Also I don't think any research is truly independent, and if you find yourself a senior professor you'll find yourself talking with other professors and exchanging ideas.

Is it not as good as me doing my own research? (and compared to students who have done their own research projects, is it a significant disadvantage?)

I don't think that an undergraduate who writes a statement of purpose that claims that they have done their own research project without significant assistance and advice from a professor is going to be taken seriously.

 

[zhaira931]

Actually all my research paper are written on my own. Although I got some idea on the different references to make my research paper more academic one. Cause if you write your own research paper, you can explain it easily.

 

[rezeew]

I can understand your concern about the type of research experience you have had so far. Let me assure you that it is not uncommon for students to have their first research experience by assisting a professor with their research. In fact, it is a great opportunity to learn from experienced researchers and gain valuable skills and knowledge in your field of interest.

When it comes to applying for graduate school, the type of research experience you have is not the only factor that is taken into consideration. Admissions committees also look at the quality of your experience and your contribution to the research project. By assisting a professor, you have shown that you are capable of working in a team, following instructions, and understanding the direction of the research. These are all valuable skills that are highly regarded in graduate school.

Of course, having your own research project is also a great experience and can demonstrate your ability to independently plan and execute a research project. However, it is not a significant disadvantage if you have not had the opportunity to do so. You can still highlight your potential for independent research in your personal statement and showcase your understanding of the research process.

In conclusion, both assisting a professor with their research and conducting your own research project have their own benefits and can contribute to your graduate school application. What matters most is the quality of your experience and your ability to showcase your skills and potential as a researcher. So, I would encourage you to continue gaining research experience in any form and make the most out of it.