Why is U minimized at constant S and V?

  • Thread starter namphcar22
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Constant
In summary: We can also derive this result using statistical mechanics, but it requires more complex calculations and assumptions about the distribution of microstates. In summary, the minimum energy principle for closed systems at constant entropy and volume can be derived using a thermodynamic argument by setting the derivative of energy with respect to volume equal to zero.
  • #1
namphcar22
7
0
Can someone explain why the energy U of a closed system at constant entropy S and volume V reaches a minimum at equilibrium? Wikipedia has an article on principle of minimum energy, but I'm a little uncomfortable with the partial derivative manipulations in that article. Is it possible to argue derive the min energy principle using statistical mechanics?

I know from my intro stat mech course that two systems are in thermal equilibrium with constant total U and V, they will distribute energy between themselves to maximize the total entropy. This fact follows from the fundamental assumption that all accessible microstates in an isolated system are equally likely. So when the dust settles, we are most likely to observe an energy division with the greatest number of corresponding microstates. However, in my original equation, entropy is fixed, so statistical arguments don't seem to be available.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
In this case, I think the best way to approach the problem is to use a thermodynamic argument. We can start by noting that the total energy of a closed system at constant entropy and volume is given by the fundamental thermodynamic relation:U = U(V, S).Since U is a function of V and S, if we hold S constant, then U is a function of V only. The minimum energy state of the system is then obtained by setting the derivative of U with respect to V equal to zero. This gives us:dU/dV = 0,which is the condition for finding the minimum energy state of the system.
 

FAQ: Why is U minimized at constant S and V?

Why is U minimized at constant S and V?

The energy of a system, U, is minimized at constant entropy (S) and volume (V) because these two variables are closely related to the stability and equilibrium of a system. At constant entropy, a system is in thermal equilibrium with its surroundings, meaning that it has reached a state of maximum randomness or disorder. Similarly, at constant volume, a system is in mechanical equilibrium, meaning that the forces acting on it are balanced. In order for a system to be in a stable and equilibrium state, both of these conditions must be met, leading to U being minimized.

How does constant S and V affect U?

At constant entropy and volume, the internal energy of a system, U, is held at its minimum value. This means that any changes in U must be accompanied by changes in either entropy or volume. For instance, if there is an increase in entropy, there must also be an increase in volume to maintain the minimum value of U. Similarly, if there is a decrease in volume, there must also be a decrease in entropy to keep U at its minimum value.

Can U ever increase at constant S and V?

No, at constant entropy and volume, U can only decrease or remain constant. This is because the conditions of constant S and V ensure that the system is in a state of maximum stability and equilibrium, and any increase in U would disrupt this balance. U can only increase if there is a change in either S or V, which would result in a change in the minimum value of U.

Why is U minimized instead of maximized at constant S and V?

The reason U is minimized at constant S and V is due to the second law of thermodynamics, which states that the total entropy of a closed system must increase over time. At constant entropy and volume, the system is already in a state of maximum entropy, so U cannot be further minimized. On the other hand, if U was maximized, it would lead to a decrease in entropy, which goes against the second law of thermodynamics.

How does the minimization of U at constant S and V relate to the stability of a system?

The minimization of U at constant S and V directly relates to the stability of a system. A system is considered stable when it is in a state of thermodynamic equilibrium, meaning that it is at a minimum energy state and all forces and energies are balanced. By minimizing U, the system is able to maintain this equilibrium and remain in a stable state. If U was not minimized, the system would be in a state of imbalance and would not be considered stable.

Back
Top