- #246
jms5631
- 64
- 0
peter0302 said:. But I cannot abide anyone dismissing the fears of the general public who cannot be expected to know any better, especially given the damage to the planet and to human health that has been done in the name of science and progress.
First of all, you are correct, even though the risk is unspeakably minute, and not taken seriously by anyone almost anyone in the scientific community, the onus is on the scientists to take appropriate measures to convince the public of their safety. CERN has done an exceptionally comprehensive and commendable job in this regard. Relative to other colliders that have been started, the amount of research into safety has been astounding, and addressed throughly. There is a limit to what they can do however. They can not erase the irrational fears held by some of the uneducated public over operative words and automatic associations that illicit nefarious images of cataclysmic destruction such as black holes. In dealing with fundamental physics, the general public has an absolute right to demand safety and security, but must ultimately defer to the experts(who want to live no less then the general public) whose knowledge far surpasses their own. Most people don't understand Heisenberg, or Hawking Radiation, or the significance of cosmic ray collisions. Most don't even understand relativity. The point being, of course, not to highlight their ignorance but to point out their need to defer to some of the most intelligent people in the world on the subject. They have every right to demand their safety, but after every measure within reason has been taken to allay their fears and demonstrate the certitutde of the scientific safety claims, enough needs to be declared enough. Every single potential scanerio I've seen, that is halfway rational of course, has been thoroughly refuted on both theoretical and observational grounds, and this machine has been shown to be safe.
Also, I'm sure you will agree that the benefits that scientific progress have brought to civilizations, which are too plentiful to enumerate here, far outweigh any negatives.