- #2,171
liamdavis
- 30
- 0
According to this site, which keeps a running tally, as of my posting time there have beenTCups said:EXTENT OF DAMAGE TO REACTOR BUILDINGS DUE TO EARTHQUAKE?
Have there been any reports of the extent and types of earthquake damage that occurred at other regional NPP's that didn't suffer catastrophic consequences of complete loss of power?
Perhaps this point was already made, but if so, I make it again. A 9.0 earthquake, in and of itself, could do significant damage to the reactor buildings. The scenarios I and others have considered in most detail follow the consequences of complete loss of all power and subsequent events related to the reactor vessels, primary containment, and spent fuel pools.
The chain of events at Fukushima with the rapid arrival of the tsunami and complete loss of power were such that, if done, there has been little or no reporting of a primary assessment of damages or likely damages due solely to the magnitude of the earthquake. Significant lateral thrusting occurred.
I am reminded of the external crack visible on Bldg 2 and must wonder if they are blast or earthquake-related, or more likely, a combination of both.
Also, in cross-section, the arrangement of a massive concrete and steel primary containment structure nested atop a huge underground torus leads me to wonder what damages the quake might have caused by the extreme forces of lateral thrusting where the two structures meet, so to speak.
Some knowledge of the specific types and locations of damages that might have been in play at Fukushima at the time power was lost would surely be helpful in sorting out what has followed.
851 quakes >4M
402 quakes >5M
51 quakes >6M
and 3 quakes >7M just since March 11, 2011.
http://www.japanquakemap.com/
By the time you go to the site it will have increased.
Over the 40 years of their operation how many quakes have the Daiichi plants endured? What ever the number it is remarkable. It may also have taken a toll that would have been very informative to analyze after decommissioning. What we cannot know is if those cumulative stresses brought some components too close to failure to withstand the latest combination of events.
liam