- #36
Tide
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
- 3,087
- 0
Ivan Seeking said:I normally allow Andre to present his arguments unchallenged. Since I don't feel that Andre is qualified to discredit global warming arguments, I felt that an objection was in order.
So, let me make sure that I understand your position: You are not only a climate expert, but also a fusion expert.
https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=41819
Got it.![]()
I stated my positions and I stand by them. I think it's highly inappropriate and offensive for a mentor to challenge points on the basis of "qualifications" as it sets a very bad example both for members of the forum and for people entering science.
Having said that, I am a physicist and I understand the workings of science. My work was in fusion and anyone should be able to intelligently discuss the merits of global climate change with or without degrees in the sciences. The fact that you posed your "query" as you did indicates that you're less interested in educating and sharing knowledge than you are in posturing. I would suggest that you adopt a less confrontational attitude and elicit views from all rather than stifling discussion.