- #1
Reuben_Leib
- 6
- 1
I am sorry I can't seem to get the LaTex to work
$$\textbf{My question:}$$
A car collides with a fast-moving bus, which vehicle experiences the greater change in momentum?
I am seem to get different answers on the internet:
Chegg says both the same,
quora says car,
brainly says car,
some youtube vids say both
Bard says: car has the greater change, but also contradics its self
I just want to confirm for myself: That the change in moment is the same?
$$\textbf{My Proof1}$$
Before collision: let total momentum = ##P_{tot}##, and ##P_{bus}## initial momentum of bus, ##P_{car}## initial momentum of car,
$$P_{bus} + P_{car} = P_{tot}$$
Let the change in momentum be ##\Delta P_{buss}## and ##\Delta P_{car}##, thus after the collision the: (using conservation of momentum)
$$P_{bus} + \Delta P_{buss} + P_{car} + \Delta P_{car} = P_{tot}$$
Now subtract the first equation from the second we get:
$$\Delta P_{buss} + \Delta P_{car} = 0$$
or
$$\Delta P_{buss} = -\Delta P_{car}$$
$$\textbf{Conclusion}$$
I believe that this proves that the change in momentum is the same in magnitude.
$$\textbf{My Proof2}$$ -by contradiction
suppose that the magnitude ##\Delta P_{buss} >\Delta P_{car}##, thus there exists ##\alpha > 0##, where ##P_{buss} = -(P_{car} + \alpha)##. The negative is needed else momentum not conserved.
but then we get:
$$-\Delta P_{car} - \alpha + \Delta P_{car} = 0$$
but then ##\alpha = 0## which is a contradiction
1. Are my proofs sound?
2. is the change in moment is the same?
Thank you for your answer.
$$\textbf{My question:}$$
A car collides with a fast-moving bus, which vehicle experiences the greater change in momentum?
I am seem to get different answers on the internet:
Chegg says both the same,
quora says car,
brainly says car,
some youtube vids say both
Bard says: car has the greater change, but also contradics its self
I just want to confirm for myself: That the change in moment is the same?
$$\textbf{My Proof1}$$
Before collision: let total momentum = ##P_{tot}##, and ##P_{bus}## initial momentum of bus, ##P_{car}## initial momentum of car,
$$P_{bus} + P_{car} = P_{tot}$$
Let the change in momentum be ##\Delta P_{buss}## and ##\Delta P_{car}##, thus after the collision the: (using conservation of momentum)
$$P_{bus} + \Delta P_{buss} + P_{car} + \Delta P_{car} = P_{tot}$$
Now subtract the first equation from the second we get:
$$\Delta P_{buss} + \Delta P_{car} = 0$$
or
$$\Delta P_{buss} = -\Delta P_{car}$$
$$\textbf{Conclusion}$$
I believe that this proves that the change in momentum is the same in magnitude.
$$\textbf{My Proof2}$$ -by contradiction
suppose that the magnitude ##\Delta P_{buss} >\Delta P_{car}##, thus there exists ##\alpha > 0##, where ##P_{buss} = -(P_{car} + \alpha)##. The negative is needed else momentum not conserved.
but then we get:
$$-\Delta P_{car} - \alpha + \Delta P_{car} = 0$$
but then ##\alpha = 0## which is a contradiction
1. Are my proofs sound?
2. is the change in moment is the same?
Thank you for your answer.