Is the Kroneker Delta Identity Used Correctly in this Paper?

In summary, the paper critically examines the application of the Kronecker delta identity within a specific mathematical context. It evaluates whether the identity is utilized appropriately, highlighting instances of misapplication and offering clarifications on its proper use. The discourse emphasizes the importance of precision in mathematical notation and the implications of erroneous interpretations on the overall findings of the research.
  • #1
Safinaz
261
8
TL;DR Summary
A question about a Kroneker Delta identity
Is there a Kroneker Delta identity:

$$ \delta^3 (k) \delta^3 (k) = \frac{2\pi^2}{k^3} ~ \delta (k_1- k_2) $$?

Where k is a wave number. In this Paper: Equations 26 and 27, I think this identity is used to make ##k_1=k_2## and there is an extra negative sign.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Could you tell us what is the relation among k, k_1 and k_2 ?
Assuming they have same dimension k, dimension of LHS is k^-6 that of RHS is k^-4. They do not coincide.
 
Last edited:
  • #3
First of all you must clearly distinguish between a Kronecker (sic!) ##\delta## and Dirac ##\delta## distributions, which refers to discrete variables, i.e.,
$$\delta_{k_1 k_2}=\begin{cases} 1 &\text{for} \quad k_1=k_2, \\
0 &\text{for} k_1 \neq k_2. \end{cases}
$$
Then you have ##\delta_{k_1k_2}^2=\delta_{k_1 k_2}##.

For Dirac-##\delta## distributions the square doesn't make any sense. Whenever it occurs somewhere, the authors make a mistake. In the paper you linked, nowhere is such a non-sensical formula though!
 
  • Like
Likes BvU

FAQ: Is the Kroneker Delta Identity Used Correctly in this Paper?

What is the Kronecker Delta Identity?

The Kronecker Delta, denoted as δ_ij, is a function of two variables, typically integers i and j. It is defined as 1 if i equals j and 0 otherwise. It is often used in summations and mathematical expressions to simplify indices and ensure that certain conditions are met.

How is the Kronecker Delta Identity typically used in mathematical papers?

The Kronecker Delta Identity is commonly used in mathematical papers to simplify sums and to enforce constraints on indices. For example, in tensor notation, it helps in reducing expressions by eliminating terms where indices do not match. It is also used in various proofs and derivations to manage and simplify mathematical expressions.

What are common mistakes when using the Kronecker Delta Identity?

Common mistakes include misinterpreting the indices, incorrectly applying the delta function in summations, and neglecting the conditions under which the delta function is 1 or 0. Another frequent error is using the Kronecker Delta in contexts where the indices do not match the intended application, leading to incorrect simplifications.

How can I verify if the Kronecker Delta Identity is used correctly in a paper?

To verify correct usage, check that the indices are correctly matched and that the delta function is applied appropriately in summations. Ensure that the conditions for the delta function (i.e., δ_ij = 1 if i = j, otherwise δ_ij = 0) are correctly interpreted and applied. Reviewing the context in which the delta function is used can also help ensure its proper application.

What should I do if I find an error in the use of the Kronecker Delta Identity in a paper?

If you find an error, you should first verify the mistake by re-evaluating the relevant mathematical expressions and context. Once confirmed, consider contacting the authors to discuss the potential error. Providing a clear explanation and any corrections or suggestions can help improve the accuracy of the paper. If necessary, you may also consider submitting a comment or erratum to the journal where the paper was published.

Back
Top