- #1
CosmicVoyager
- 164
- 0
What caused and is causing space to increase or expand?
Greetings,
The answer to a major question has raised another problem...then solution...then questions.
Why didn't gravity keep everything together at the big bang like a black hole? Because *all* of space was filled with matter/energy so gravity pulled equally on everything from all directions. There was no place where gravity was stronger. It is like being at the center of the earth. You are surrounded by matter, but the net effect of gravity is zero. But unlike the earth, at the beginning of the universe the center was everywhere, either because the universe is hypersherical or because it is infinite.
Yay! Problem solved. But wait. This would also be true for all forces. Matter/energy being everywhere would mean every force was pulling equally on everything in all directions, so the net effect of any force was zero. So there was no force to push things apart! So how the heck did the universe expand?
I suddenly realized that the universe was not expanding because a force was pushing matter/energy apart, but because space was increasing! The distance between particles was not increasing because of a force pushing them or because they had velocity, but the distance was increasing because the space between them was increasing! Wow! The particles were not actually moving apart. The space they were in was moving! Epiphany!
This raises other questions...
What does it mean exactly for space to expand?
And what caused (and is causing) space to expand?
Thanks
Greetings,
The answer to a major question has raised another problem...then solution...then questions.
Why didn't gravity keep everything together at the big bang like a black hole? Because *all* of space was filled with matter/energy so gravity pulled equally on everything from all directions. There was no place where gravity was stronger. It is like being at the center of the earth. You are surrounded by matter, but the net effect of gravity is zero. But unlike the earth, at the beginning of the universe the center was everywhere, either because the universe is hypersherical or because it is infinite.
Yay! Problem solved. But wait. This would also be true for all forces. Matter/energy being everywhere would mean every force was pulling equally on everything in all directions, so the net effect of any force was zero. So there was no force to push things apart! So how the heck did the universe expand?
I suddenly realized that the universe was not expanding because a force was pushing matter/energy apart, but because space was increasing! The distance between particles was not increasing because of a force pushing them or because they had velocity, but the distance was increasing because the space between them was increasing! Wow! The particles were not actually moving apart. The space they were in was moving! Epiphany!
This raises other questions...
What does it mean exactly for space to expand?
And what caused (and is causing) space to expand?
Thanks
Last edited: