Analysis of Performance of Rotary Vane Compressor

[sam_nich]

Hello all.

I have the following questions regarding the analysis of the performance of a rotary vane compressor.

1) Why can the specific kinetic and potential energy changes normally be neglected?
2) If an adiabatic compression is considered, what is the primary cause of energy loss by heat transfer from the system using a (water) cooling jacket?
3) What possible causes could explain a lack of energy balance in the SFEE?

Thanks.

 

[Mech_Engineer]

Hello all.

I have the following questions regarding the analysis of the performance of a rotary vane compressor.

1) Why can the specific kinetic and potential energy changes normally be neglected?
2) If an adiabatic compression is considered, what is the primary cause of energy loss by heat transfer from the system using a (water) cooling jacket?
3) What possible causes could explain a lack of energy balance in the SFEE?

Thanks.

I'll try to answer these, it all has to do with trying to simplify the thermodynamic state of the air in the compressor to more easily decide where it is.

1)
a) The changes in kinetic energy can be ignored because the air is traveling relatively slowly. The air would have to be traveling at speeds similar to a trubine for the kinetic energy to make a significant difference. For a compressor, the energy is being stored as pressure work, not kinetic.
b) For this, the fact is that a compressor is small, not several hundred feet tall. because of this, even if the air moves to a larger height, it's not enough to need to take into account. Even with water, it takes a column height of about 667 feet to store one BTU of energy, a lot of height for a little energy.

2) This question doesn't really make sense, because an adiabatic compression means that there is a perfectly insulated control volume enclosing your compression process, which means a water cooling jacket cannot apply... A water cooling jacket would usually be used in conjunction with a very slow compression to try to approximate an ISOTHERMAL compression, where the air in the compression cylinder stays as close to constant temperature as possible. The problem with this is that the compressions take a very long time, and usually an ISENTROPIC compression is used to approximate a compressor. However, for an isentropic compresison with a water cooling jacket, the main losses would be in the form of heat conducted into the water.

3) Lack of energy balance is easy to guess at. Losses in the entire assembly due to friction should be a first guess, since to have a good seal in the piston you muct have some frictional losses. Additionally, an isothermal compression is theoretically the most efficient compresison you can have. Any heat that is lost from the compressor is an energy loss. So, the farther you are from this form of compression, the less efficent you are. Usually, compressors follow closer to an isentropic compression, but even then you are not folowing it exactly due to real-world losses.

EDIT: Since it is a rotary vane compressor, another possibly significant loss could be from the viscous losses in the fluid, depending on how fast you are compressing the fluid and its associated Reynold's number.

 

[ravenprp]

1) The specific kinetic and potential energy changes can usually be neglected because they are relatively small compared to the overall energy changes in the compressor. In a rotary vane compressor, the majority of energy changes occur due to changes in pressure and temperature, rather than changes in kinetic or potential energy.

2) In an adiabatic compression, the primary cause of energy loss by heat transfer is due to the compression process itself. As the gas is compressed, its temperature increases, and some of this energy is lost to the surroundings through the cooling jacket. This is because the compressor is not perfectly insulated and some heat will always be transferred to the surrounding environment.

3) A lack of energy balance in the SFEE (steady flow energy equation) could be caused by several factors. One possible cause could be measurement errors in the input and output parameters used in the equation. Another possible cause could be leakage in the compressor, which would result in a decrease in the amount of work done by the compressor and therefore a lack of energy balance. Additionally, any mechanical or operational inefficiencies in the compressor could also contribute to a lack of energy balance.