Anyone have time to check my Jacobian for this transformation?

In summary, the conversation was about checking the Jacobian for a given transformation and determining if it was correct. The original calculation resulted in a Jacobian of zero, causing doubt, but after further calculations and corrections, the correct Jacobian was determined to be 2xyz. The conversation also touched on the difficulty of the class and the help being received.
  • #1
Theelectricchild
260
0
Anyone have time to check my Jacobian for this transformation!?

[tex]x = e^{u-v}[/tex] [tex]y = e^{u+v}[/tex] [tex]z = e^{u+v+w}[/tex]

I ended up getting the Jacobian as ZERO.

This is why I am doubting myself--- it seems wrong! What do you guys get?

Thanks for you help. :redface:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
the jacobian isn't zero, check your calculations, you might have a bad sign...
 
  • #3
Yeah i screwed up --- i got something like 2^(u-v) * (e^2u+2v+w)

does that look oK?
 
  • #4
whoops i mean [2*e^(u-v)] * [(e^2u+2v+w)]
 
  • #5
You still may be off: I get 2eu+v+we2u= 2e3u+v+w.

(Edited after jdavel pointed out an error.)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #6
Halls of Ivy,

You have a typo in your final answer. That should be 3u, not 2u.

Theelectricchild, to keep from confusing the signs, it helps (at least in this case, since exp(x) is its own derivative) to find all nine derivates and then write the determinant in terms of x, y and z. Then, with those two beautiful zeros, the Jacobian = 2xyz is almost staring you in the face.
 
Last edited:
  • #7
Thx for your help guys--- I find this class a big leap in difficulty from where we left off in our calculus III course which was on tangent planes--- I am glad I am getting help. Ugh now to get ready for Friday's midterm.
 

FAQ: Anyone have time to check my Jacobian for this transformation?

What is a Jacobian in relation to transformations?

The Jacobian is a matrix of partial derivatives used to transform a set of variables from one coordinate system to another. It represents the local linear transformation at a point and is often used in multivariate calculus and differential equations.

Why is it important to check the Jacobian for a transformation?

The Jacobian ensures that the transformation is valid and accurate. It is used to calculate the correct scaling factor and direction of the transformation, and can help identify errors or inconsistencies in the transformation.

How do I calculate the Jacobian for a given transformation?

The Jacobian can be calculated by taking the partial derivatives of each output variable with respect to each input variable and arranging them in a matrix. The matrix can then be evaluated at a specific point in the transformation to obtain the local transformation matrix.

Can the Jacobian be used for any type of transformation?

Yes, the Jacobian can be used for any type of transformation, including linear and nonlinear transformations. It is a general mathematical tool that is widely applicable in various fields of science and engineering.

Is there a specific format or notation for writing a Jacobian matrix?

While there are different notations for writing a Jacobian matrix, the most common format is to list the partial derivatives in a matrix with the input variables on the left and the output variables on the right. The notation may vary depending on the specific application or discipline.

Back
Top