- #1
NTL2009
- 622
- 386
This has bugged me for years. The Butterball Turkey site has instructions for thawing a frozen turkey in water. I've done this before, and my experience does not match their description. They say:
https://www.butterball.com/products/whole-turkey/frozen
A frozen turkey is going to be around 0 degrees F (typical home freezer). Tap water temperature varies, but probably ~ 60 F in much of the US. The turkey cools the water down. In the early stages, ice can form on the turkey, insulating it from the water, and keeping the turkey surface below freezing. How can adding more 60 F tap water "keep the surface of the turkey cold"? I've found I had to change the water because the water was too cold, so defrosting was going too slow.
It really seems to me their reasoning is backwards, you change the water (which has been cooled by the turkey) to warm the turkey, so it defrosts. When I've done this, I monitor the temperature of the water, if a 20# turkey is going to take 10 hours, I don't want it sitting in 60F water, I want that water at 40F or less to slow bacterial growth.
Thoughts?
https://www.butterball.com/products/whole-turkey/frozen
To thaw more quickly, place unopened turkey breast down in sink filled with cold tap water. Allow 30 minutes per pound. Change water every 30 minutes to keep surface of turkey cold.
A frozen turkey is going to be around 0 degrees F (typical home freezer). Tap water temperature varies, but probably ~ 60 F in much of the US. The turkey cools the water down. In the early stages, ice can form on the turkey, insulating it from the water, and keeping the turkey surface below freezing. How can adding more 60 F tap water "keep the surface of the turkey cold"? I've found I had to change the water because the water was too cold, so defrosting was going too slow.
It really seems to me their reasoning is backwards, you change the water (which has been cooled by the turkey) to warm the turkey, so it defrosts. When I've done this, I monitor the temperature of the water, if a 20# turkey is going to take 10 hours, I don't want it sitting in 60F water, I want that water at 40F or less to slow bacterial growth.
Thoughts?