Are Electrons and Photons Like Water Molecules and Waves?

  • Thread starter thetexan
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Act Waves
In summary, the conversation discusses the similarities between water waves and the behavior of electrons and photons. The writer questions why these particles behave as waves and suggests that it may be because they are so numerous and interact with each other in interesting patterns. They also consider the concept of "dark matter" and propose that the universe may be filled with an "ether" of particles. However, they acknowledge that their thinking may be flawed and ask for clarification.
  • #1
thetexan
269
12
I was reading about the two slot experiment and how electrons appear to be wavelike as well as particlelike. How can this be the writer asked. It started me to consider water waves and what they are.

We never think of water as a single molecule. We always think of it as what we observer, a fluid mass of lots of single molecules and they always interact in the form of waves. Waves, at least as water is concerned, is the flowing of many molecules over each other in interesting patterns we call waves.

We think of electrons and photons as particles and wonder why they behave as a wave. It would seem at an elementary level of reasoning that, like water, these particles are so numerous that they behave in interesting patterns called waves.

So where are the rest of them? Think about this. Every cubit nanometer of the universe is filled to the brim with photons and cosmic particles of every kind. The proof of this is as follows. Imagine you are floating in space observing all of the lovely photons from all of the stars and galaxies in the universe. Move your eye to the right 1 inch. You still observe the stars and galaxies. In fact, no matter where you move you light receptors (eyes) you capture photons from limitless origins. Now, try to put you eye in a 'light void' where you can not see any light from the stars. It can't be done. That is because photons are everywhere, permeating every cubit femtometer of the universe. Add to this all of the other particles of various kinds and it's obvious the space is a soup of 'stuff'. There's nothing empty about it. Perhaps this is the dark matter we talk about. It seems to me that we actually do have an 'ether'...an ether of particles.

In any case, like a ocean of water molecules, each of these particles can act as a single particle (in fact, that's precisely what they are) and they appear as waves only because of the ocean of particles interacting with each other.

A universe of water waves and water molecules...or, better stated, a universe of elementary particles and the associated waves.

Where am I going wrong with this thinking?

tex
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
1) the wave of water is described by the intensity that is equal to the square of its wave height, while the elections wave is described by the probability to find the elections at particular location
2) the electrons wave can be still observed even if we use a single electon while water wave cannot be treated at the same footing
 

Related to Are Electrons and Photons Like Water Molecules and Waves?

1. Why do particles act like waves?

Particles exhibit wave-like behavior because they have both particle-like and wave-like properties. This is known as wave-particle duality, a concept in quantum mechanics. The behavior of particles can be described using probability waves, which determines the likelihood of a particle being in a certain location at any given time.

2. How can particles have both particle and wave properties?

According to the principles of quantum mechanics, particles exist in a state of superposition, which means they can exist in multiple states or locations simultaneously. This allows particles to exhibit both particle-like and wave-like behavior at the same time.

3. What is the evidence for particles behaving like waves?

The most well-known evidence for wave-particle duality is the double-slit experiment. In this experiment, particles are fired at a barrier with two slits, and they produce a wave-like interference pattern on the other side, indicating that they behave like waves. Other evidence includes the photoelectric effect and electron diffraction experiments.

4. Can all particles behave like waves?

Yes, all particles exhibit wave-particle duality, including light, electrons, protons, and even larger particles such as atoms and molecules. However, the degree to which a particle exhibits wave-like behavior depends on its mass and speed. Larger and slower particles tend to have more noticeable wave-like behavior.

5. Why is understanding wave-particle duality important?

Understanding wave-particle duality is crucial in the field of quantum mechanics, which is the study of the behavior of particles at the subatomic level. It has also led to important discoveries and technologies such as the development of the transistor, which is the basis for modern electronics. Additionally, it challenges our understanding of the fundamental nature of reality and the relationship between matter and energy.

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
608
  • Quantum Physics
2
Replies
36
Views
3K
  • Quantum Physics
2
Replies
38
Views
3K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
9
Views
690
Replies
16
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
6
Views
739
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
991
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
14
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
21
Views
1K
Back
Top