Are Libertarians and Anarchists Free from Indoctrination?

  • Thread starter kasse
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses the argument that libertarians are indoctrinated and that humans do not have basic rights by nature. It also brings up the idea that only anarchists are not indoctrinated. However, the other person strongly disagrees and points out that even anarchists end up with complicated rules when forming a society. Noam Chomsky's view on the closest modern humans have gotten to an anarchic state is also mentioned, along with a first-hand description of an anarchist society in Northern Spain by George Orwell. The person challenges the idea of indoctrination in this society and asks for the other person's thoughts after reading the description.
  • #1
kasse
384
1
Can it be argued that libertarians are indoctrinated, that humans have no basic rights by nature, and that the only people not to be indoctrinated are anarchists?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Anything can be argued.
 
  • #3
russ_watters said:
Anything can be argued.

I strongly disagree with your post.
 
  • #4
kasse said:
Can it be argued that libertarians are indoctrinated, that humans have no basic rights by nature, and that the only people not to be indoctrinated are anarchists?
Even anarchists, when they try to actually formally coalesce into a society, end up with the most complicated rules. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rAaWvVFERVA"

Noam Chomsky, a supporter of the notion of anarchy, had said that the closest modern humans had ever gotten to n anarchic state was in Northern Spain before Franco took over. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_Revolution" contains a first-hand description (and endorsement) of this society by George Orwell. Read it, and tell me if you can sense any indoctrination behind the anarchy.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

FAQ: Are Libertarians and Anarchists Free from Indoctrination?

What is the definition of a libertarian?

A libertarian is someone who believes in the principles of limited government, individual liberty, and free markets. They advocate for minimal government intervention in both personal and economic matters.

Are libertarians indoctrinated into their beliefs?

No, libertarians are not indoctrinated into their beliefs. Like any political ideology, individuals may be influenced by their surroundings and experiences, but ultimately their beliefs are formed by their own critical thinking and evaluation of different ideas.

How do libertarians view government and authority?

Libertarians believe that government should have a limited role in society and should only be responsible for protecting individual rights and enforcing contracts. They view excessive government control and authority as a threat to personal freedom and individual responsibility.

What values do libertarians prioritize?

Libertarians prioritize individual liberty, personal responsibility, and voluntary interactions. They believe that individuals have the right to make their own choices as long as they do not harm others, and that government should not interfere with these choices.

Do libertarians believe in any government programs or regulations?

Some libertarians may support limited government programs and regulations that align with their principles of individual liberty and free markets. However, in general, libertarians advocate for a smaller government with less involvement in social and economic affairs.

Similar threads

Back
Top