- #1
Luke_Mtt
- 2
- 0
- TL;DR Summary
- Hi everyone,
I recently started approaching for the first time to the quantum mechanics field by reading the book of Susskind and Friedman "Quantum Mechanics, The Theoretical Minimum" but I couldn't figure how the authors can express some spin state in function of two (orthogonal) base spin states (II chapter).
Practically it is said that, given two spin states |u⟩ (up) and |d⟩ (down) - which are the spin measured along the +z and -z semiaxes - such that they are orthogonal ( ⟨u|d⟩ = ⟨d|u⟩ = 0), it is possible to write any other spin states using a linear combination of these two (because they are a base of the states' vector space). So it is:
|A⟩ = αu |u⟩ + αd |d⟩ = ⟨u|A⟩ |u⟩ + ⟨d|A⟩ |d⟩
It is then said that given a spin state |A⟩, the probability to measure up or down (|u⟩ and |d⟩) spin states are:
Pu = ⟨A|u⟩ ⟨u|A⟩ = ⟨u|A⟩* ⟨u|A⟩ = αu* αu
Pd = ⟨A|d⟩ ⟨d|A⟩ = ⟨d|A⟩* ⟨d|A⟩ = αd* αd
(where x* is the complex conjugate)
Then, the total probability is 1 so that:
αu* αu + αd* αd = 1.
Which is equivalent to say that |A⟩ is normalized to the unit (⟨A|A⟩ = 1)
Then it is introduced another vector cuple considered as another base. This two vectors, |r⟩ (right) and |l⟩ (left) represent the spin state along the +x and -x semiaxes. Quoting verbatim the book it is said that "If a spin state |A⟩ prepares the initial state |r⟩, and an instrument that stores the spin value is rotated (from |r⟩ because it has prepared it) to measure the z axe's spin (σz), the probability to obtain up or down is the same (because the x axe is perpendicular to the z one), so it must be: αu* αu = αd* αd = ½". Then the authors state that a vector which satisfy this conditions is, for example:
|r⟩ = αu |u⟩ + αd |d⟩ = ⟨u|r⟩ |u⟩ + ⟨d|r⟩ |d⟩ = 1/√2 |u⟩ + 1/√2 |d⟩
After, they say, in addition to a phase ambiguity (please, can you make me understand this point too, because I couldn't figure out what phase ambiguity is), |r⟩ and |l⟩ must satisfy ⟨l|r⟩ = ⟨r|l⟩ = 0 too because of the fact of being a base of the vector space. They then say that this conditions bind the |l⟩ vector to take the form:
|l⟩ = αu |u⟩ + αd |d⟩ = ⟨u|l⟩ |u⟩ + ⟨d|l⟩ |d⟩ = 1/√2 |u⟩ - 1/√2 |d⟩
Then they repeat almost the same procedure for the y axe. So, calling |i⟩ (in) and |o⟩ (out) the spin state along the +y and -y semiaxes it is possible to use this two spin state as a base, provided that ⟨i|o⟩ = ⟨o|i⟩ = 0. Then it is known that:
αu* αu = ⟨u|o⟩* ⟨u|o⟩ = ⟨o|u⟩ ⟨u|o⟩ = ½ // αu* αu in function of o
αd* αd = ⟨d|o⟩* ⟨d|o⟩ = ⟨o|d⟩ ⟨d|o⟩ = ½ // αd* αd in function of o
αu* αu = ⟨u|i⟩* ⟨u|i⟩ = ⟨i|u⟩ ⟨u|i⟩ = ½ // αu* αu in function of i
αd* αd = ⟨d|i⟩* ⟨d|i⟩ = ⟨i|d⟩ ⟨d|i⟩ = ½ // αd* αd in function of i
And also because y is orthogonal both at z and at x it mus be
αr* αr = ⟨r|o⟩* ⟨r|o⟩ = ⟨o|r⟩ ⟨r|o⟩ = ½ // αr* αr in function of o
αl* αl = ⟨l|o⟩* ⟨l|o⟩ = ⟨o|l⟩ ⟨l|o⟩ = ½ // αl* αl in function of o
αr* αr = ⟨r|i⟩* ⟨r|i⟩ = ⟨i|r⟩ ⟨r|i⟩ = ½ // αr* αr in function of i
αl* αl = ⟨l|i⟩* ⟨l|i⟩ = ⟨i|l⟩ ⟨l|i⟩ = ½ // αo* αo in function of i
So, they say, apart from the phase ambiguity, the vectors for |i⟩ and |o⟩ which satisfies this conditions are:
|i⟩ = αu |u⟩ + αd |d⟩ = ⟨u|i⟩ |u⟩ + ⟨d|i⟩ |d⟩ = 1/√2 |u⟩ + i/√2 |d⟩
|l⟩ = αu |u⟩ + αd |d⟩ = ⟨u|o⟩ |u⟩ + ⟨d|o⟩ |d⟩ = 1/√2 |u⟩ - i/√2 |d⟩
Finally, the thing I couldn't understand, apart from the phase ambiguity, is "how the authors came up with the αu and αd coefficients for |r⟩, |l⟩, |i⟩, |o⟩"? Did they already know that this coefficients would have worked with that specific conditions or there is a process behind this choice? If it is, which calculus do I have to do to derive these coefficients?
P.S. My english is not perfect, so sorry for eventual errors.
Thank you for your time!
|A⟩ = αu |u⟩ + αd |d⟩ = ⟨u|A⟩ |u⟩ + ⟨d|A⟩ |d⟩
It is then said that given a spin state |A⟩, the probability to measure up or down (|u⟩ and |d⟩) spin states are:
Pu = ⟨A|u⟩ ⟨u|A⟩ = ⟨u|A⟩* ⟨u|A⟩ = αu* αu
Pd = ⟨A|d⟩ ⟨d|A⟩ = ⟨d|A⟩* ⟨d|A⟩ = αd* αd
(where x* is the complex conjugate)
Then, the total probability is 1 so that:
αu* αu + αd* αd = 1.
Which is equivalent to say that |A⟩ is normalized to the unit (⟨A|A⟩ = 1)
Then it is introduced another vector cuple considered as another base. This two vectors, |r⟩ (right) and |l⟩ (left) represent the spin state along the +x and -x semiaxes. Quoting verbatim the book it is said that "If a spin state |A⟩ prepares the initial state |r⟩, and an instrument that stores the spin value is rotated (from |r⟩ because it has prepared it) to measure the z axe's spin (σz), the probability to obtain up or down is the same (because the x axe is perpendicular to the z one), so it must be: αu* αu = αd* αd = ½". Then the authors state that a vector which satisfy this conditions is, for example:
|r⟩ = αu |u⟩ + αd |d⟩ = ⟨u|r⟩ |u⟩ + ⟨d|r⟩ |d⟩ = 1/√2 |u⟩ + 1/√2 |d⟩
After, they say, in addition to a phase ambiguity (please, can you make me understand this point too, because I couldn't figure out what phase ambiguity is), |r⟩ and |l⟩ must satisfy ⟨l|r⟩ = ⟨r|l⟩ = 0 too because of the fact of being a base of the vector space. They then say that this conditions bind the |l⟩ vector to take the form:
|l⟩ = αu |u⟩ + αd |d⟩ = ⟨u|l⟩ |u⟩ + ⟨d|l⟩ |d⟩ = 1/√2 |u⟩ - 1/√2 |d⟩
Then they repeat almost the same procedure for the y axe. So, calling |i⟩ (in) and |o⟩ (out) the spin state along the +y and -y semiaxes it is possible to use this two spin state as a base, provided that ⟨i|o⟩ = ⟨o|i⟩ = 0. Then it is known that:
αu* αu = ⟨u|o⟩* ⟨u|o⟩ = ⟨o|u⟩ ⟨u|o⟩ = ½ // αu* αu in function of o
αd* αd = ⟨d|o⟩* ⟨d|o⟩ = ⟨o|d⟩ ⟨d|o⟩ = ½ // αd* αd in function of o
αu* αu = ⟨u|i⟩* ⟨u|i⟩ = ⟨i|u⟩ ⟨u|i⟩ = ½ // αu* αu in function of i
αd* αd = ⟨d|i⟩* ⟨d|i⟩ = ⟨i|d⟩ ⟨d|i⟩ = ½ // αd* αd in function of i
And also because y is orthogonal both at z and at x it mus be
αr* αr = ⟨r|o⟩* ⟨r|o⟩ = ⟨o|r⟩ ⟨r|o⟩ = ½ // αr* αr in function of o
αl* αl = ⟨l|o⟩* ⟨l|o⟩ = ⟨o|l⟩ ⟨l|o⟩ = ½ // αl* αl in function of o
αr* αr = ⟨r|i⟩* ⟨r|i⟩ = ⟨i|r⟩ ⟨r|i⟩ = ½ // αr* αr in function of i
αl* αl = ⟨l|i⟩* ⟨l|i⟩ = ⟨i|l⟩ ⟨l|i⟩ = ½ // αo* αo in function of i
So, they say, apart from the phase ambiguity, the vectors for |i⟩ and |o⟩ which satisfies this conditions are:
|i⟩ = αu |u⟩ + αd |d⟩ = ⟨u|i⟩ |u⟩ + ⟨d|i⟩ |d⟩ = 1/√2 |u⟩ + i/√2 |d⟩
|l⟩ = αu |u⟩ + αd |d⟩ = ⟨u|o⟩ |u⟩ + ⟨d|o⟩ |d⟩ = 1/√2 |u⟩ - i/√2 |d⟩
Finally, the thing I couldn't understand, apart from the phase ambiguity, is "how the authors came up with the αu and αd coefficients for |r⟩, |l⟩, |i⟩, |o⟩"? Did they already know that this coefficients would have worked with that specific conditions or there is a process behind this choice? If it is, which calculus do I have to do to derive these coefficients?
P.S. My english is not perfect, so sorry for eventual errors.
Thank you for your time!