Calculate Relative Speeds of Moving Objects for Twin Paradox

  • Thread starter Alkatran
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses the concepts of relativity and velocity transformations. The participants address a question about how to calculate the velocity of an object in a moving reference frame and suggest using the velocity addition law. They also discuss the twin paradox and how to model it in a computer program. Finally, they touch on the concept of slopes in reference frames and mention the use of the Lorentz transform.
  • #1
Alkatran
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
959
0
I understand the ideas behind relativity (4d space time, different speeds see different slices of it, what not), but I've never done the math.

If I have something traveling at v1 relative to some frame, and another thing traveling at v2, what is v2 transformed into the reference frame moving at v1?

I'm trying to model the twin paradox in a computer program.

Oh, and how do I calculate the slope of a reference frame relative to another reference frame? Is it just (+-)gamma?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
You need to use the velocity-transformations.
 
  • #3
Alkatran said:
If I have something traveling at v1 relative to some frame, and another thing traveling at v2, what is v2 transformed into the reference frame moving at v1?
Suppose you're on a train moving with velocity u relative to the ground, and you walk forward with velocity v relative to the train, your velocity relative to the ground is not u+v but (u+v)/(1+uv). (I'm using units in which c=1. Otherwise this would be (u+v)/(1+uv/c²).)

This is the relativistic velocity addition law.

You seem to be asking for a slightly different version of it (if I understand you correctly). Suppose a train is moving with velocity v1 relative to the ground, and some guy is walking with speed v2 relative to the ground, then what is this guy's speed relative to the train?

According to the velocity addition law it is (-v1+v2)/(1+(-v1)v2).

Alkatran said:
Oh, and how do I calculate the slope of a reference frame relative to another reference frame? Is it just (+-)gamma?
Suppose that another observer is moving with velocity v in the coordinate system where you are stationary at the origin, and that you both measure time from an event when both of your origins were at the same place, then his t axis in a spacetime diagram that represents your coordinates is a line through the origin with slope 1/v (remember that t is in the "up" direction), and his x-axis is a line through the origin with slope v. Each line that is parallell to his x-axis represents a set of events that are simultaneous to him.

Note that the when the astronaut twin has changed his direction, these lines of simultaneity ("slices" of spacetime that he thinks of as space at different times) will be very different from what they were before.
 
  • #4
Alkatran said:
I understand the ideas behind relativity (4d space time, different speeds see different slices of it, what not), but I've never done the math.

If I have something traveling at v1 relative to some frame, and another thing traveling at v2, what is v2 transformed into the reference frame moving at v1?

That's just a velocity subtractin problem. Classically the answer is v2-v1, relativistically the answer is (v2-v1)/(1+v1*v2/c^2)

I'm trying to model the twin paradox in a computer program.

Oh, and how do I calculate the slope of a reference frame relative to another reference frame? Is it just (+-)gamma?

That would probably depend on how you draw the reference frame. In any event, you should be able to figure it out from the Lorentz transform.

I prefer the following version

[edit! Major ooops!]

x' = gamma*(x - v t)
t' = gamma*(t - v x)

where
gamma = 1/sqrt(1-v^2)

the inverse of which is

x = gamma*(x' + v t')
t = gamma*(t' + v x')

[end edit]

but note that the require that you use "relativistic" units, where time for example might be measured in seconds and distance in light seconds, or time in years and distance in light years.
 
Last edited:

FAQ: Calculate Relative Speeds of Moving Objects for Twin Paradox

What is the Twin Paradox?

The Twin Paradox is a thought experiment in the theory of relativity that explores the concept of time dilation. It involves two identical twins, one who stays on Earth and the other who travels through space at high speeds. When the traveling twin returns to Earth, they will have experienced less time compared to their twin who stayed on Earth.

How do you calculate relative speeds of moving objects in the Twin Paradox?

The relative speed between two objects can be calculated using the formula v = (d/t), where v is the relative speed, d is the distance between the objects, and t is the time it takes for the objects to travel that distance. In the Twin Paradox, the relative speed between the twins can be calculated using the distance traveled and the time experienced by each twin.

What are the key factors that contribute to the Twin Paradox?

The key factors that contribute to the Twin Paradox are the constant speed of light, the principle of relativity, and the concept of time dilation. The constant speed of light means that the speed of light is the same for all observers, regardless of their relative motion. The principle of relativity states that the laws of physics are the same for all observers in uniform motion. Time dilation occurs when an object is moving at high speeds, causing time to appear to pass slower for that object.

How does the Twin Paradox challenge our understanding of time?

The Twin Paradox challenges our understanding of time by showing that time is not absolute and can be affected by factors such as speed and acceleration. It also demonstrates the concept of time dilation, which suggests that time can pass at different rates for different observers depending on their relative motion. This goes against our everyday experience of time as a constant and unchanging concept.

Can the Twin Paradox be proven through experiments?

The Twin Paradox has been proven through experiments using atomic clocks on airplanes and satellites that travel at high speeds. These experiments have shown that time does indeed pass slower for objects in motion compared to those at rest, confirming the predictions of the theory of relativity. However, the Twin Paradox is ultimately a thought experiment and cannot be directly tested due to the limitations of our current technology.

Similar threads

Back
Top