Calculating Torque for Stopping Rotating Body - Confirm & Comment

  • Thread starter mechdesignron
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Torque
In summary: If not, then I suggest finding a physics textbook or website that covers this type of calculation.In summary, Ron is trying to calculate the torque required to stop a rotating object (in terms of ft*lb*s^2) using formulas that he has learned from a textbook. However, he is confused by the difference between force and mass, and needs help understanding how to solve for torque.
  • #1
mechdesignron
9
0
I would like someone to confirm, comment on my understanding of torque calculations of a rotating body.
Formula: [tex]T[/tex]=[tex]I[/tex][tex]\alpha[/tex]
[tex]I[/tex]=LB-FT2 (1366.5) Known
[tex]\alpha[/tex]=Rad/s2(43.33)
Angular acceleration from 600-0 RPM in 1.45 sec

Now I believe I need to divide by 32.2 ft/s2 (accelleration of gravity)
This should give me FT-Lbs torque required to (stop) 1366.5 inertia in 1.45 sec.

Please confirm that this is correct with units.

Thank You

Ron
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
mechdesignron said:
I would like someone to confirm, comment on my understanding of torque calculations of a rotating body.
Formula: [tex]T[/tex]=[tex]I[/tex][tex]\alpha[/tex]
[tex]I[/tex]=LB-FT2 (1366.5) Known
[tex]\alpha[/tex]=Rad/s2(43.33)
Angular acceleration from 600-0 RPM in 1.45 sec

Now I believe I need to divide by 32.2 ft/s2 (accelleration of gravity)
This should give me FT-Lbs torque required to (stop) 1366.5 inertia in 1.45 sec.

Please confirm that this is correct with units.

Thank You

Ron

Woah there Speedy Gonzales. If you need to include gravity in there then you haven't fully defined the problem for us PFers. Recommend you describe the situation you are trying to solve for.

EDIT: Allow me to elaborate. In a uniform gravitational field, gravity won't effect the stopping torque. That is to say, that all things being equal, it takes the same torque to rotate the same inertia in any gravitational reference frame. If you are simply trying to convert to other units, then please specify.
 
  • #3
I am testing a brake

Ok, I know I have 1366.5 LB-Ft2 of material spinning at 600 RPM, I stop that in 1.45 seconds. What is the torque generated to do that.

I would think that gravity would not be a factor but when I ommit the gravatational constant the results I get are not really possible.

IE: 1366.5 LB-FT2*43.33 Rad/s2=59210.5 FT-Lbs
Add the grav constant: 1366.5 LB-FT2*43.33 Rad/s2/32.2 Ft/s2=1838.8 Ft-Lbs

The later awnser makes sence, I would like someone to confirm that it is correct. Also adding the Grav constant Ft/s2 helps the dimensional analysis.

The first awnser cannot be right. If I use it to calculate my COF I get a value of over 1(Impossible)

Let me know what you think.

Thanks
Ron
 
  • #4
Inertia is a property of matter, but momentum is a property of motion. Calculate your angular momentum.

This sounds suspiciously like a homework problem, so I won't go any further.
 
  • #5
This is not a homework problem,

Is there someone who understands this enough to at least tell me if what I am doing is wrong. Inertia is a bodys resistance to motion, I have a steel disc, with its weight and diameter I can calculate its inertia, it is spinning at 600 Revolutions per minute. I want to find the torque required to stop this in 1.45 seconds. Torque, rotational force applied to a body. We could also look at this as how much torque is required to take 1366.5 LB-FT^2 from 0-600 RPM in 1.45 seconds.

If you do not understand the problem, please don't comment. I occasionally submit questions to forums but often look at them for information and it is very frustratrating reading through commentary.
 
  • #6
mechdesignron said:
The first awnser cannot be right. If I use it to calculate my COF I get a value of over 1(Impossible)

mechdesignron said:
This is not a homework problem,

Is there someone who understands this enough to at least tell me if what I am doing is wrong.[?]

If you do not understand the problem, please don't comment. I occasionally submit questions to forums but often look at them for information and it is very frustratrating reading through commentary.

Well, Ron... I would start with your textbook.

Firstly, there's nothing that says coefficient of friction can't be over 1 (which is what led me to believe you were still a student). For example, aluminum against aluminum is over 1. Some silica rubbers against concrete are over 1. Examples are not exotic and are easy to find.

Secondly, I'll give you some help to get you on the right track, but this STILL sounds academic...

Solve for angular momentum: L = Iw (w = omega... sorry about not using Latex)
Solve for torque: t = dL/dt

Start there. If nothing else, your dimensional analysis should've told you that your answer doesn't work.
 
  • #7
mechdesignron said:
Now I believe I need to divide by 32.2 ft/s2 (accelleration of gravity)
This should give me FT-Lbs torque required to (stop) 1366.5 inertia in 1.45 sec.

You are correct.

The issue arises from the fact that the "lb" is a unit of force, not mass. By dividing your inertia by accel due to gravity (32.2 ft/s^2 in this case), you will convert it to a mass based inertia (US mass unit is the "slug" (m=W/g)).

By dividing by gravity, you convert inertia units from lb*ft^2 (weight based, which is confusing) to lb*ft*s^2 (mass based, which is still perhaps confusing).

Using this in your calculation will result in proper torque units of ft*lb.

If you have been exposed to SI units, you may find it simpler to convert to kg and N*m from the start, or just use them for checking.
 

FAQ: Calculating Torque for Stopping Rotating Body - Confirm & Comment

What is torque and how does it relate to stopping a rotating body?

Torque is a measure of the force that causes an object to rotate around an axis. When a rotating body is stopped, torque is applied in the opposite direction of the rotation to slow down and eventually stop the body.

How do you calculate torque for stopping a rotating body?

To calculate torque for stopping a rotating body, you need to know the moment of inertia, angular velocity, and the time it takes to stop. The formula is torque = moment of inertia x angular velocity / time.

How does the moment of inertia affect the torque needed to stop a rotating body?

The moment of inertia is a measure of an object's resistance to changes in its rotation. The higher the moment of inertia, the more torque is needed to stop the rotating body.

Is there a specific unit for torque when calculating for a rotating body?

Yes, the unit for torque is Newton-meters (Nm) in the metric system and pound-feet (lb-ft) in the imperial system.

Can torque be negative when calculating for stopping a rotating body?

Yes, torque can be negative when the direction of the rotation is opposite of the applied force to stop the body. This indicates that the torque is acting in the opposite direction of the rotation, slowing it down.

Similar threads

Back
Top