- #1
zanick
- 383
- 23
- TL;DR Summary
- Since orbits are considered geodesic paths, objects following these paths are considered "in freefall" in Einstein physics. Can gyroscopes detect the constant turn of an orbital path, even though it is considered to be inertial, or in "freefall" as its path is dictated by the warping of spacetime?
Einstein said, when describing someone falling off a building, that the Earth accelerating up to meet him/her. Without the Earth getting larger in all directions as the paradox goes, it curvature of space-time which is why you can have the acceleration up without the surface moving up as you follow a geodesic path. Any deviation from that geodesic will requires a force which is what causes you to have weight on a scale on earth.
However, what if we consider an orbiting satellite which is also considered in free fall. It has gyroscopes on board for maintaining or changing orientation. Do they only measure rotational changes with respect to the geodetic path? I mean, if I think about the inertial state, say you are moving slowly through space in a capsule, with no windows, and you came across a large planet I would think that you divert to the direction of the 'planet',(Due to the warping of spacetime) and you would never know it, as you would still in be in "freefall" Even still, you accelerate, still you feel no acceleration. Then you orbit the planet, So, will the original orientation of the capsule will be held in position? Would it be whatever was in line to your direction through spacetime originally with respect to the planet?
In other words, if the top of the capsule was pointed forward through space time, would it also and always point in line with the geodesic path? And now the real question, would any gyros that happen to be spinning on board, notice an orbital path and the approach to the orbital path? If so, would the gyroscope or craft roll back every revolution around the planet, or would it remain aligned with the geodetic path and not vary its position and would the gyro sense this?
I understand that gyros are fixed in space and detect any kind of deviation, but I'm thinking that if the gyroscope follows the geodesic path (The curved path) of the space capsule, that there would be no forces acting on it, except when the orientation would vary from that path.
Thanks for the help.
However, what if we consider an orbiting satellite which is also considered in free fall. It has gyroscopes on board for maintaining or changing orientation. Do they only measure rotational changes with respect to the geodetic path? I mean, if I think about the inertial state, say you are moving slowly through space in a capsule, with no windows, and you came across a large planet I would think that you divert to the direction of the 'planet',(Due to the warping of spacetime) and you would never know it, as you would still in be in "freefall" Even still, you accelerate, still you feel no acceleration. Then you orbit the planet, So, will the original orientation of the capsule will be held in position? Would it be whatever was in line to your direction through spacetime originally with respect to the planet?
In other words, if the top of the capsule was pointed forward through space time, would it also and always point in line with the geodesic path? And now the real question, would any gyros that happen to be spinning on board, notice an orbital path and the approach to the orbital path? If so, would the gyroscope or craft roll back every revolution around the planet, or would it remain aligned with the geodetic path and not vary its position and would the gyro sense this?
I understand that gyros are fixed in space and detect any kind of deviation, but I'm thinking that if the gyroscope follows the geodesic path (The curved path) of the space capsule, that there would be no forces acting on it, except when the orientation would vary from that path.
Thanks for the help.