Can anyone please verify/check if there's error in this word problem?

In summary, the equation is solved as follows: x=2244+98t and y=-4556+199t. The smallest non-negative integer solution is found to be t=23.
  • #1
Math100
797
221
Homework Statement
When Mr. Smith cashed a check at his bank, the teller mistook the number of cents for the number of dollars and vice versa. Unaware of this, Mr. Smith spent 68 cents and then noticed to his surprise that he had twice the amount of the original check. Determine the smallest value for which the check could have been written.
[Hint: If x denotes the number of dollars and y the number of cents in the check, then 100y+x-68=2(100x+y).]
Relevant Equations
None.
Proof: Let x be the number of dollars and y be the number of cents in the check.
Then we have 100y+x-68=2(100x+y).
From the hint, we get the following Diophantine equation: -199x+98y=68.
Applying the Euclidean Algorithm produces:
199=2(98)+3
98=32(3)+2
3=1(2)+1
2=2(1)+0.
Now we have gcd(199, 98)=1.
Note that 1##\mid##68.
Since 1##\mid##68, it follows that the Diophantine equation -199x+98y=68 can be solved.
Then we have 1=3-2(1)
=3-(98-32(3))
=33(3)-98
=33(199-2(98))-98
=33(199)-67(98).
This means 68=68[33(199)-67(98)]
=2244(199)-4556(98).
Thus, x\_{o}=2244 and y\_{o}=-4556.
All solutions in the integers are determined by:
x=2244+\frac{98){1}t=2244+98t for some t \in \mathbb{Z},
y=-4556-\frac{-199}{1}t=-4556+199t for some t \in \mathbb{Z}.
Therefore, x=2244+98t and y=-4556+199t.
To find the smallest non-negative integer solutions,
we solve for t:
2244+98t ##\geq## 0 ##\land## -4556+199t ##\geq## 0
t##\geq####\frac{-1122}{49}## ##\land## t##\geq####\frac{4556}{199}##.
Thus, t=23, which implies that x=2244+98(23)=4498 and y=-4556+199(23)=21.

And now I am confused right here, because the answer in my textbook says "The smallest value for which the check could have been written is $10.21, but it doesn't seem like I am getting closer to this final answer/result, although the y-value is 21 does seem reasonable. Can anyone please verify/check my proof for this problem and spot any calculation error or something if anything is incorrect? Thank you.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
In the Diophantine equation, you have ##-199x##, so I think you should have ##x_o = -2248##.
 
  • Like
Likes Math100
  • #3
vela said:
In the Diophantine equation, you have ##-199x##, so I think you should have ##x_o = -2248##.
Then how should I set up the equation from 3-(98-32*3)=33(3)-98=33(199-2*98)-98?
 
  • #4
The rest of your work is fine as is. Comparing the Diophantine equation you started with to what you ended up with, it seems that
$$68=2244(199)-4556(98) = -\underbrace{(-2244)}_{x_o}(199)+\underbrace{(-4556)}_{y_o}(98).$$ Note that the wrong result you got, 4498, is equal to ##2\times 2244+10##. Because you used the wrong sign for ##x_o##, you added 2244 instead of subtracting 2244, resulting in the difference of ##2\times 2244##.
 
  • Like
Likes Math100 and sysprog
  • #5
vela said:
The rest of your work is fine as is. Comparing the Diophantine equation you started with to what you ended up with, it seems that
$$68=2244(199)-4556(98) = -\underbrace{(-2244)}_{x_o}(199)+\underbrace{(-4556)}_{y_o}(98).$$ Note that the wrong result you got, 4498, is equal to ##2\times 2244+10##. Because you used the wrong sign for ##x_o##, you added 2244 instead of subtracting 2244, resulting in the difference of ##2\times 2244##.
Now I got it. Thank you so much for the help!
 

FAQ: Can anyone please verify/check if there's error in this word problem?

What is the purpose of verifying/checking for errors in a word problem?

The purpose of verifying/checking for errors in a word problem is to ensure that the problem is accurately stated and that the solution is correct. This helps to avoid any mistakes or misunderstandings when solving the problem.

How do you verify/check for errors in a word problem?

To verify/check for errors in a word problem, you can follow these steps:

  • Read the problem carefully to understand the given information and what is being asked.
  • Check for any missing or incorrect information.
  • Double check the calculations and equations used in the solution.
  • Compare your solution with the given answer (if any) to see if they match.
  • If possible, ask someone else to review the problem and solution for any errors.

Why is it important to verify/check for errors in a word problem?

Verifying/checking for errors in a word problem is important because it ensures the accuracy and validity of the problem and its solution. It helps to avoid mistakes and misunderstandings that can lead to incorrect solutions and wasted time.

What are some common errors to look out for in a word problem?

Some common errors to look out for in a word problem include:

  • Missing or incorrect information
  • Incorrect use of units or conversions
  • Calculation errors
  • Incorrect application of formulas or equations
  • Misinterpretation of the problem

Can someone else verify/check a word problem for me?

Yes, it is always a good idea to have someone else review a word problem and its solution for any errors. This can help to catch any mistakes that may have been overlooked and ensure the accuracy of the problem and solution.

Back
Top