Can This Seemingly Impossible Mathematical Series Be Solved?

  • Thread starter hagopbul
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Body
In summary: Unfortunately, complex expressions can often be just as informative (or even more so!) in solving a problem.
  • #1
hagopbul
376
39
i have this problem and i am Trying to solve but it seems impossible so I need help
(even matmatica unable solve it )
seriesSum((2L+1)·(e^((((-((h)^(2)))·L·(L+1))/(2 J K)),L,0,∞)))

or :
seriesSum((2l+1)·(e^((((-((h)^(2)))·l·(l+1))/(2 J K)),l,0,∞)))

SO TRY YOUR LUKE HERE.:wink:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
hagopbul said:
i have this problem and i am Trying to solve but it seems impossible so I need help
(even matmatica unable solve it )
seriesSum((2L+1)·(e^((((-((h)^(2)))·L·(L+1))/(2 J K)),L,0,∞)))

or :
seriesSum((2l+1)·(e^((((-((h)^(2)))·l·(l+1))/(2 J K)),l,0,∞)))

SO TRY YOUR LUKE HERE.:wink:

I doubt very much that Mathematica can't do it. I suspect you just don't LIKE Mathematica's answer! Since your sum has several powers of L in the numerator, and only constants in the denominator, the individual terms do NOT go to 0 and so the sum does not converge. (I am assuming that you (2 J K) is just the product of three numbers and not some special notation you chose not to define!)
 
  • #3
no you don't understand no body even Mathematica can do it i try
so i need help? even if you don't type 2*j*k
mathematica can't solve it.
 
  • #4
I bet It would be much easier to do if you rewrote it for us without so many Brackets. I am not even going to bother trying to decipher that.
 
  • #5
hagopbul said:
no you don't understand


No, *you* don't understand: since the terms do not tend to zero (according to HallsOfIvy), the sum does not exist. Further, even if it did exist, Mathematica would be able to tell you what it was, but not necessarily in a 'nice' closed formula involving the variables. You have made the common mistake of thinking that some thing is the answer if and only if it is a nice simple expression.
 

FAQ: Can This Seemingly Impossible Mathematical Series Be Solved?

What is an impossible problem?

An impossible problem is a complex issue or challenge that seems too difficult or even impossible to solve with current knowledge, resources, or technology.

How do scientists approach impossible problems?

Scientists approach impossible problems by breaking them down into smaller, more manageable parts and using the scientific method to gather data, make observations, and test hypotheses. They also collaborate with other experts and utilize advanced technology and techniques.

What strategies can be used to solve impossible problems?

Some strategies that can be used to solve impossible problems include thinking outside the box, considering multiple perspectives, analyzing potential consequences, and utilizing creativity and innovation. It is also important to constantly reassess and adapt strategies as new information becomes available.

What role do failure and mistakes play in solving impossible problems?

Failure and mistakes are an essential part of the problem-solving process. They provide valuable learning opportunities and can lead to new insights and approaches. It is important for scientists to embrace failure and view it as a necessary stepping stone towards finding a solution.

Can impossible problems ever truly be solved?

While some problems may seem impossible to solve, history has shown that significant advancements and breakthroughs can occur when scientists and experts work together and continue to push the boundaries of knowledge. While a perfect solution may not always be achievable, progress and improvement can still be made towards solving impossible problems.

Back
Top