Can Wave and Particle Be Separated in a Modified Double-Slit Experiment?

In summary, the conversation discusses the Bohmian interpretation of quantum mechanics and how it explains the behavior of particles and waves in the 2-slit experiment. It also touches on the possibility of experimental verification of this interpretation and the perspective of de Broglie, the originator of the theory. While the Bohmian interpretation offers interesting insights, it cannot be fully tested or proven through experiments due to the limitations of macroscopic measuring apparatuses.
  • #1
C. Bernard
23
1
If the 2-slit experiment is modified by adding apartition between the barrier and the electron detector screen, forming 2 compartiments, the particle willgo in one of the slit, but what about the wave? If it slill goes through the 2 slits,will the wave and the particle be separated? If not, how will it know a partition has been added?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #3
Thank you Demystifier,
so if i understood you ,according to the Bohmian theory,in the case i described, using a photon, the particle aspect would go through one slit and the wave aspect through both? So that they would be separated.
Could this be verified experimentally?
 
  • #4
And also de Broglie's theory (from which Bohmian theory arose). De Broglie, from what I've read, found Bohmian theory interesting but did not necessarily endorse it. Instead he continued to develop and re-think or clarify his own theory.
 
  • #5
C. Bernard said:
Thank you Demystifier,
so if i understood you ,according to the Bohmian theory,in the case i described, using a photon, the particle aspect would go through one slit and the wave aspect through both? So that they would be separated.
Yes.

C. Bernard said:
Could this be verified experimentally?
Yes and no. Namely, the measurable predictions of Bohmian theory are the same as those of standard theory without particle trajectories. Particle trajectories cannot be measured in practice. Namely, if you try to measure trajectory, you must introduce interaction with a measuring apparatus. The interaction disturbs the wave function in a very complicated way, so the resulting trajectory (depending on the wave function) is very different from the trajectory without interaction that you wanted to measure. In fact, it can be shown that the influence of the measuring apparatus is such that the measured trajectory will always look as a classical trajectory, which is a consequence of the fact that a measuring apparatus is always a macroscopic object. But that result can be obtained even without the Bohmian theory. In other words, macroscopic apparatuses cannot distinguish different microscopic interpretations of quantum mechanics. A microscopic apparatus could, in principle, distinguish different interpretations, but in practice there is no such thing as microscopic measuring apparatus.

Another idea is to use a macroscopic apparatus with a very weak interaction, which does not disturb the wave function. Such a measurement is not a true measurement in the usual sense, but when one uses it to measure particle trajectories, one really gets Bohmian trajectories. But still, even standard quantum theory predicts that such a measurement will get Bohmian trajectories, so such a measurement does not prove that the Bohmian interpretation is right. For more details see
https://www.physicsforums.com/blog.php?b=3077
 
Last edited by a moderator:

FAQ: Can Wave and Particle Be Separated in a Modified Double-Slit Experiment?

What is the wave-particle duality?

The wave-particle duality is a fundamental concept in quantum mechanics that describes the behavior of particles, such as electrons, as both a wave and a particle. This means that particles can exhibit characteristics of both waves and particles, depending on how they are observed or measured.

How can something be both a wave and a particle?

This concept may seem counterintuitive, but it is supported by experimental evidence. The behavior of particles is described by wave functions, which are mathematical representations of the probability of finding a particle at a certain location. This means that particles do not have a definite position or velocity, but rather exist as a wave of probabilities.

What experiments demonstrate the wave-particle duality?

One of the most famous experiments is the double-slit experiment, in which a particle is fired at a barrier with two narrow slits. The resulting pattern on the other side shows interference fringes, similar to what would be expected from a wave. Other experiments, such as the photoelectric effect, also support the wave-particle duality.

How does the wave-particle duality impact our understanding of the physical world?

The wave-particle duality challenges our traditional understanding of the physical world and has led to the development of the field of quantum mechanics. It has also led to the development of technologies, such as electron microscopes and transistors, that rely on the wave-like behavior of particles.

Is there a way to predict whether a particle will behave as a wave or a particle?

No, there is no way to predict with certainty how a particle will behave. The behavior of particles is described by probabilities, and the outcome of an experiment can only be determined by observing the particle. This is known as the principle of complementarity in quantum mechanics.

Similar threads

Replies
36
Views
4K
Replies
24
Views
740
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
18
Views
2K
Replies
33
Views
3K
Back
Top