Classifying Critical Points when the 2nd derivative test FAILS

In summary, The person is having trouble classifying critical points when the second derivative test fails for a given function. They have found one critical point at (0,0) and are trying to determine if it is the only possible critical point. They suggest using cross sections to get a better understanding of the surface and potentially classify the point. They also mention considering the values of z along lines through the critical point to determine positivity as a function of the parameter a.
  • #1
jegues
1,097
3
I'm having some trouble classifying critical points when the 2nd derivative test fails.

The function is,

[tex]f(x,y) = x^4 - 3x^2y^2 + y^4[/tex]

The only critical point I've found is (0,0). How do I know that this is the only possible critical point?

Anyways, the second derivative test fails for this point, so I've got to classify it another way.

I can try to get a rough idea of what the surface looks like by drawing cross sections, and maybe I can get a good enough picture to classify my point.

Set x=0,

z = y^4

Set y=0,

Z = x^4

So at the bottom sits my critical point and I have to parabolas in the y-z plane and x-z plane.

This makes me think my point may be a relative min.

How can I figure out whether all values of Z are positive or not?

Any ideas/suggestions?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
All lines through the critical point are of the form [tex]y= ax[/tex]. You can consider the values of [tex]z[/tex] along these lines and determine the positivity as a function of the parameter [tex]a[/tex].
 

FAQ: Classifying Critical Points when the 2nd derivative test FAILS

What is the 2nd derivative test?

The 2nd derivative test is a mathematical method used to determine the critical points of a function. It involves taking the second derivative of the function and analyzing its sign at the critical points to determine whether they are maxima, minima, or points of inflection.

What does it mean when the 2nd derivative test fails?

When the 2nd derivative test fails, it means that the test is inconclusive and cannot determine the nature of the critical point. This usually occurs when the second derivative is equal to zero or undefined at the critical point.

Why is it important to classify critical points?

Classifying critical points allows us to understand the behavior of a function and identify important points such as maxima and minima. This information can be useful in various applications, such as optimization problems and curve sketching.

What other methods can be used to classify critical points when the 2nd derivative test fails?

Other methods that can be used include the 1st derivative test, the concavity test, and the closed interval method. These methods involve analyzing the slope and concavity of the function at the critical point to determine its nature.

Can there be more than one critical point when the 2nd derivative test fails?

Yes, it is possible for there to be multiple critical points when the 2nd derivative test fails. This can occur when the function has points of inflection or when the second derivative is equal to zero at more than one point.

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
730
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
468
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Back
Top