Comparison Theorem for integrals

In summary, the speaker is asking for advice on how to use the comparison theorem to determine if a given function converges or diverges. They provide information on the function and its leading terms, and suggest using a test function g(x) to establish convergence. They also mention the ease of integration for the given function.
  • #1
Corky
14
0
I have to use the comparison theorem to find if the function converges or diverges. Any ideas as to what I can use to compare the function to??

integrate: sqrt(1 + sqrt(x))/sqrt(x)dx
Using the comparison theorem!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
You need a function g(x) for which your function (call it f(x)) satisfies the following:

limx-->∞(f/g)=k

where k is a positive real number.

Look at the leading terms in the numerator and denominator of f(x). Rewriting your function f(x) in radical form, it looks like.

f(x)=(x1/2+1)/x1/2

For large x, we can ignore the "+1" in the numerator to get:

f(x)~x1/4/x1/2=x-1/4

g(x) looks to me like a good choice for your test function. Why? Because it is easy to establish the convergence of that integral (I assume you are integrating from 1 to infinity or something like that). Try the limit comparison test on that and see what happens.

Also, your original function is easy to integrate, so you can check your answer. Just let u=x1/2 and so du=(1/2)x-1/2.

edit: fixed HTML code
 
  • #3
(1 + x^1/2)/x <= ((1 + x^1/2)/x)^1/2 for all x >= 1.
Thus since the integral of(1 + x^1/2)/x diverges as does the original function.
Thanks
 

FAQ: Comparison Theorem for integrals

What is the Comparison Theorem for integrals?

The Comparison Theorem for integrals is a mathematical theorem that states if two functions are continuous and one is greater than the other, then their integrals also follow the same relationship. This means that if the integral of one function is greater than the integral of another function, then the first function is greater than the second function.

How is the Comparison Theorem applied in real-world situations?

The Comparison Theorem is often used in real-world situations to estimate values of integrals that are difficult to compute. By finding a simpler function that is greater than the given function, we can use the Comparison Theorem to determine the upper bound of the integral. This is particularly useful in physics and engineering, where complex integrals often arise.

What are the limitations of the Comparison Theorem for integrals?

One limitation of the Comparison Theorem is that it only works for continuous functions. If the functions are not continuous, then the theorem may not hold true. Additionally, the theorem may not be applicable if the functions have different domains.

What is the relationship between the Comparison Theorem and the Squeeze Theorem?

The Comparison Theorem and the Squeeze Theorem are closely related. The Squeeze Theorem is a special case of the Comparison Theorem where the upper and lower bounds of the functions are the same, resulting in the same value for the integrals. In other words, the Comparison Theorem is a generalization of the Squeeze Theorem.

How can I prove the Comparison Theorem for integrals?

The Comparison Theorem can be proved using the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus and the properties of integrals. It involves breaking down the integral into smaller parts and using the comparison property of integrals to show that the original integral is either greater than or equal to the integral of the simpler function. A rigorous proof can be found in most calculus textbooks.

Similar threads

Back
Top