Cosine and sine of 2Pi/5 problem

In summary: If you have calculated ##\omega^5##, can you calculate ##1-\omega^5## ?Yes, I can calculate ##1-\omega^5##, it is equal to 0 since ##\omega^5## equals 1.
  • #1
cdummie
147
5
We have a complex number ω = cos(2π/5) +isin(2π/5) and we have two complex numbers a and b, such that:

a= ω + ω4 and b= ω2 + ω3. I have to prove that a + b = -1 and a*b= -1. Then, based on that, determine cos(2π/5) and sin(2π/5).

I've tried to solve this using trigonometry. First a+b, i got:

cos(2Pi/5) + cos(4Pi/5) + cos(6Pi/5) + cos(8Pi/5) + i[ sin(2Pi/5) + sin(4Pi/5) + sin(6Pi/5) + sin(8Pi/5)]

then i tried expressing cos(6Pi/5) as cos(2Pi/5 + 5Pi/5) = cos(2Pi/5)cos(4Pi/5) + sin(2Pi/5)sin(4Pi/5)

and cos(4Pi/5) as cos2(2Pi/5) - sin2(2Pi/5). But that wasn't helpful. Knowing that a + b equals -1 that means that this whole expression should end up as cosPi + isinPi since that is equal to -1. But i just can't get there.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Are you familiar with the Euler formula ?
Mark your ##\omega^n## terms in a and b on a unit circle in the complex plane and see what that brings you...
 
  • #3
BvU said:
Are you familiar with the Euler formula ?
Mark your ##\omega^n## terms in a and b on a unit circle in the complex plane and see what that brings you...

I know Euler's formula in this example i'd have: ## ω=e^\frac{i2π}{5} ## or for a + b i would have: ## a+b = e^\frac{i2π}{5} + e^\frac{i4π}{5} + e^\frac{i6π}{5} + e^\frac{i8π}{5}## but i don't know how this helps...

When i draw a unit circle i don't see much, i mean i see the points that represent corresponding complex numbers but i don't see how it gets me closer to the solution.
 
  • #4
When i draw a unit circle i don't see much, i mean i see the points that represent corresponding complex numbers but i don't see how it gets me closer to the solution.
Do you see the same thing I see ? Addition of complex numbers is like vector addition in the x,y plane.
Can you post your sketch ?
 
Last edited:
  • #5
BvU said:
Do you see the same thing I see ? Addition of complex numbers is like vector addition in the x,y plane.
Can you post your sjetch ?

Here is the sketch:
krug.jpg


But, i can't see what will i get exactly by just looking at this picture (i'd like you to explain it to me though), and i'd like to know if there's any algebraic way to solve this?
 
  • #6
BvU said:
Addition of complex numbers is like vector addition in the x,y plane.
So where are a and b in the picture ?
 
  • #7
BvU said:
So where are a and b in the picture ?

a would be somewhere in the middle of the positive part of x-axis in the circle (even though it seems a little bit closer to zero, but this is just a sketch) and b is on the negative part of the x-axis in the circle little bit closer to (-1,0)
 
  • #8
Mark44 said:
Are you sure that you have written the problem correctly? From your problem description and your graph, it seems to me that a + b should equal 0. ω2 + ω3 add to -2cos(36°), while ω + ω4 add to +2cos(72°). It seemed simpler to write these angles in degrees...
I do get a*b = -1, but I don't get a + b = -1.
I'm confused now. I do get a+b=-1 with the same results for a and b as you.
Mark44 edit: I made a mistake in my calculations, so the text that Samy_A is quoting is in error. I have also deleted my reply that is quoted above.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #9
Samy_A said:
I'm confused now. I do get a+b=-1 with the same results for a and b as you.
Oops, my mistake. I'll go back and edit my earlier post.
 
  • #10
Have you calculated ## ω^5, ω^6, ω^7 ## to calculate ##a \cdot b##? And are you familiar with polynomial divisions?
There is an interesting generalization of the 3rd binomial formula ## (x-1)(x+1) = x^2 -1 ## for ##x^n -1##.
 
  • #11
cdummie said:
a would be somewhere in the middle of the positive part of x-axis in the circle (even though it seems a little bit closer to zero, but this is just a sketch) and b is on the negative part of the x-axis in the circle little bit closer to (-1,0)
Check b: it should be outside the circle (a.b is supposed to give -1, remember ?)

And: what is ##\omega^5## :smile: ?
 
Last edited:
  • #12
Maybe you can use the fact that if ##w## is an n-th root of unity, then EDIT ##1+ w+w^2+...+w^n =0 ## , changing the proof a bit to adapt it to your situation.
 
  • #13
BvU said:
Check b: it should be outside the sircle (a.b is supposed to give -1, remember ?)

And: what is ##\omega^5## :smile: ?

Oh i see now, b IS outside, but it's somewhere outside of circle, just like a is somewhere inside circle, that won't help if i don't know where they are exactly.
##\omega^5 = 1##
 
  • #14
BvU said:
Check b: it should be outside the circle (a.b is supposed to give -1, remember ?)

And: what is ##\omega^5## :smile: ?

So, what can i do next?
 
  • #15
cdummie said:
We have a complex number ω = cos(2π/5) +isin(2π/5) and we have two complex numbers a and b, such that:

a= ω + ω4 and b= ω2 + ω3. I have to prove that a + b = -1 and a*b= -1. Then, based on that, determine cos(2π/5) and sin(2π/5).

cdummie said:
Here is the sketch:
View attachment 92127
Use your drawing.
a + b = ω + ω4 + ω2 + ω3
ω and ω4 are the two complex numbers on the right side of the drawing. They have the same x-coordinate and their y-coordinates are opposites. Similarly, ω2 and ω3 are on the left side of the drawing. Their x-coordinates are equal and their y-coordinates are opposite in value.

Ordinary trig can be used to show that a + b = -1.

For the product ab, it's helpful to know that ω, ω2, ω34, and ω5 are all equally spaced around the unit circle, and that higher powers simply retrace certain lower powers. By that I mean that ω6 = ω, ω7 = ω2, and so on.
 
  • #16
It's difficult to help you without giving away too much. So far we've established that a and b are real and that 0<a<1 and -2<b<-1.

You have also seen that ##
\omega^5 = 1## which makes ab = a + b ##\ \ \ ## (clear ?)

Unfortunately, Mark's 'ordinary trig' doesn't help me other than that I can confirm a + b = -1 numerically. But the exercised wanted us to prove it.

For that we can now do something useful with ##0 = \omega^5 - 1\ \ \ ## -- see hint by fresh in post #10

:smile: lovely exercise !
--
 
  • #17
BvU said:
Unfortunately, Mark's 'ordinary trig' doesn't help me other than that I can confirm a + b = -1 numerically.
Yes, you're correct. I just used a calculator to get a value, but didn't show it algebraically.
BvU said:
:smile: lovely exercise !
Yes!

To expand slightly on the hint from fresh_42 that BvU mentions, the idea is related to these facts:
##(x - 1)(x + 1) = x^2 - 1##
##(x - 1)(x^2 + x + 1) = x^3 - 1##
##(x - 1)(x^3 + + x^2 + x + 1) = x^4 - 1##
and so on. This idea can be helpful in evaluating a*b.
 
Last edited:
  • #18
a + b = ω + ω4 + ω2 + ω3.
You can add 1 to it and rearrange the terms: a+b+1= 1+ω+ω234. It is a the sum of the first five elements of a geometric progression. You certainly know the formula of the sum.
If you expand ab+1 and use that ω5 = 1, you get the same sum.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes BvU
  • #19
ehild said:
a + b = ω + ω4 + ω2 + ω3.
...
Didn't we want to leave something for cd to discover ?
 
  • #20
BvU said:
Didn't we want to leave something for cd to discover ?
How about the stereographic projection?
 
  • #21
Stereographic projection ? If you mean the picture: made us see what we were after !
 
Last edited:
  • #22
BvU said:
Stereographic projeetion ? If you mean the picture: made us see what we were after !
I mean it would be something about complex numbers to explore and possibly a natural next eureka moment. It would fit the context.
 
  • #23
Not so sure. I haven't figured out how to get ab = -1 out of the picture, nor a+b = -1
 
  • #24
BvU said:
Not so sure. I haven't figured out how to get ab = -1 out of the picture, nor a+b = -1
Neither did I but after a short glimpse I haven't even tried. It was much harder not to post the solution right away. Therefore my post #10. My suggestion about stereographic projection was merely meant as an answer to your post about something left to discover. I remember a calculation on complex numbers which took me two substitutions and a couple of tricks while the author just called it obvious. It just seemed to me to be another useful tool when dealing with complex numbers. We already had Euler and roots of unity.
 
  • #25
BvU said:
Didn't we want to leave something for cd to discover ?
That was discovered by the OP already (Post #3) and also appeared in Mark's Post #15, adding 1 appeared inWWGD's Post #12 :smile:, only nobody mentioned geometric progression , which the OP is certainly familiar with, and provides an easy solution.
 
  • #26
Something else to discover about 72°:oldsmile:, but not connected to the OP.

Halve the 72° angle of the isoceles triangle in the picture. The blue triangle is similar to the original one, and both the pink and blue triangles are isosceles. From similarity, you get the relation between a and b, and it is easy to derive the sine and cosine of 72° from here.

72grades.jpg
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes BvU

FAQ: Cosine and sine of 2Pi/5 problem

1. What is the value of the cosine and sine of 2Pi/5?

The value of cosine of 2Pi/5 is approximately -0.809 and the value of sine of 2Pi/5 is approximately 0.587.

2. How do you find the cosine and sine of 2Pi/5?

To find the cosine and sine of 2Pi/5, you can use a calculator or a trigonometric table. Alternatively, you can use the trigonometric identities of double angle formulas for cosine and sine.

3. Why is 2Pi/5 a commonly used angle in trigonometry?

2Pi/5 is a commonly used angle in trigonometry because it is an irrational number and therefore cannot be expressed as a fraction. This makes it a useful angle for proving and deriving trigonometric identities.

4. What is the relationship between cosine and sine of 2Pi/5?

The relationship between cosine and sine of 2Pi/5 is that they are complementary angles. This means that the cosine of 2Pi/5 is equal to the sine of the complementary angle, which is Pi/2 - 2Pi/5.

5. How can the cosine and sine of 2Pi/5 be applied in real world situations?

The cosine and sine of 2Pi/5 can be applied in various real world situations, such as in navigation and astronomy for calculating angles and distances, in engineering for designing structures and machines, and in physics for analyzing wave patterns and vibrations.

Similar threads

Replies
15
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top