Crum's shell effect - visualisation needed

In summary, the concept of diffusion in relation to expanding and contracting bubbles in liquid is that a liquid shell forms around the bubble, which becomes thinner and more concentrated on expansion, leading to an increased rate of diffusion from the shell into the bubble. Conversely, on contraction, the shell would become thicker and less concentrated, making diffusion into the bubble less likely. This is supported by research, which states that the concentration gradient is a key factor in diffusion.
  • #1
rwooduk
762
59
When a bubble in liquid expands or contracts it can be seen as having a liquid shell that gets larger on expansion and smaller on compression.

The idea of diffusion is what I am struggling with, if the bubble was getting bigger and the liquid shell contracts then surely it would become more concentrated and diffusion into the bubble from the liquid would be reduced? likewise if the bubble was getting smaller the liquid shell would get bigger and it would be less concentrated, therefore diffusion from the liquid into the bubble would increase?

BUT Crum did not say this, he said the opposite, i'll quote a paper:

The gas diffusion is controlled by the thickness of a diffusion layer or a shell that is formed in the liquid surrounding the bubble (the bubble is assumed to be surrounded by a constant mass of liquid). When the bubble is expanded, the shell becomes thinner and the concentration gradient increases. In this case, the flow rate of gas to the bubble also increases. When the bubble is compressed, the shell is thicker as a result the concentration gradient decreases.

The problem is the language is vague, it says "to the bubble", do they mean into the bubble, do they mean molecules move to the bubble wall and stay there?

Any help with this idea would really be appreciated. Why would diffusion into the bubble occur more readily if the concentration of the wall was increased? which would intuitively make it harder for gas molecules to penetrate.

Paper source: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0307904X0300204X
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I'll update for anyone else who comes across this, now solved. The key was that it occurs from the shell and is the same substance as the bulk solution, therefore it's simply a concentration gradient issue. Here's what I have written:

On expansion, a liquid shell surrounding the bubble may be envisaged that becomes thinner and more concentrated and thus the rate of diffusion from the shell into the bubble increases. On contraction the shell would become larger it’s concentration would decrease therefore the aforementioned diffusion would not readily occur [24].
 

FAQ: Crum's shell effect - visualisation needed

What is Crum's shell effect?

Crum's shell effect, also known as the shell model effect, is a phenomenon observed in atomic nuclei where the nucleons (protons and neutrons) arrange themselves in shells similar to the electron shells in an atom. This results in certain nucleon numbers being more stable than others.

How does the shell effect affect the stability of atomic nuclei?

The shell effect plays a significant role in determining the stability of atomic nuclei. Nuclei with magic numbers of nucleons, which are numbers that correspond to complete shells, tend to be more stable than those with non-magic numbers. This is because the nucleons in complete shells have lower energy levels, making them less likely to undergo nuclear reactions.

Can the shell effect be visualized?

Yes, the shell effect can be visualized using a nuclear binding energy curve, which plots the average binding energy per nucleon against the number of nucleons in a nucleus. The peaks on this curve correspond to the magic numbers, indicating the increased stability of nuclei with those numbers of nucleons.

What are some real-world applications of Crum's shell effect?

The shell effect has many applications, particularly in nuclear physics and nuclear engineering. It is used to explain the stability and structure of atomic nuclei, as well as to predict the properties of new and unstable nuclei. The knowledge gained from studying the shell effect has also led to advancements in nuclear energy and medicine.

What is the significance of Crum's shell effect in our understanding of the universe?

The shell effect is crucial in our understanding of the universe as it helps us explain the abundance of certain elements and isotopes. The stability of atomic nuclei, determined by the shell effect, plays a significant role in the formation of elements through nuclear reactions in stars and supernovae. Without this understanding, we would not be able to fully comprehend the composition and evolution of our universe.

Back
Top