Determining motor/control options to act on a spring

In summary, the conversation discusses the design of a power hammer using a 1200lb leaf spring to actuate the upper anvil and the selection of a motor and controller for the project. The leaf spring has a Spring Rate of ~300lb/in and the desired travel of the anvil is 4-6 inches. The suggested motor is a 3HP farm-duty motor with a speed reduction via v-belt pulleys and further speed control through a VFD. The calculation procedure for determining the necessary motor horsepower is also discussed for confirmation of the motor and controller setup.
  • #1
TPayne
1
0
I'm building a power hammer for a buddy's forge and am working through the design phase. We are going to use a 1200lb leaf spring to actuate the upper anvil. Pretty much got the mechanical design down, but having some issues with the selection of motor and control.

The leaf spring we selected has a Spring Rate of ~300lb/in (force required to compress 1"). We would like the anvil to move 4-6" (travel of the spring is 5"--but this design pivots at CL through some pillow bearings). I feel that this means we need 1000lbf to mechanically act on the leaf spring but THROUGH a v-drive belt pulley system. I found these at automationdirect.com:

https://www.automationdirect.com/ad.../ac_motors/conveyor-z-farm_duty/mtf2-003-1b18

https://www.automationdirect.com/ad...quency_drives_(vfd)/general_purpose/gs21-23p0

We will have 230V single phase power, that's why the phase converter for a 3ph AC induction motor. I really feel like farm-duty is the way to go for the motor, but am not confident that a 3HP motor will provide enough power...especially because (with the motor speed being 1800RPM) I will be doing a speed reduction (6:1?) via the v-belt pulleys to get the RPM down. Any further speed control will be via the VFD with the goal to get all the way to <60RPM strikes at the anvil.

Before throwing $1000 at a motor and controller I wanted to see if anyone with more physics/mechanical/electrical engineering experience could confirm that this motor/controller setup I linked meets our intended needs (Listed:
-speed control down to 40RPM via VFD
-single phase 220V input
-motor HP sufficient for force required to actually strike the anvils with force
 

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2022-03-23 at 13.36.51.png
    Screen Shot 2022-03-23 at 13.36.51.png
    35.7 KB · Views: 104
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
The calculation procedure is as follows:

1) Assume stroke is 5 inches, peak RPM is 300, and peak force on the connecting rod is 1000 lbs.

2) The maximum torque at the drive pulley is 1000 lbs X 2.5 inch radius = 2500 inch-lbs. This includes the worst case assumption that peak force will be with the crankshaft at 90 degrees to the connecting rod. If you can positively guarantee that the peak force will be at a different crank position, then you need to calculate the worst case torque.

3) Horsepower at the drive pulley = 2500 X 300 / 63,025 = 12 hp. The 63,025 is the conversion factor to calculate horsepower given RPM and torque in in-lbs.

4) You need to check with the VFD manufacturer (it might be in their installation manual) to find the minimum percent RPM at which the motor/drive combination will develop full torque.

Keep in mind that TEFC and ODP motors generate heat in proportion to the actual torque, but the cooling capacity is proportional to RPM. Extended running at low RPM and high torque will overheat the motor. It's not a problem if the duty cycle is low enough - just shut it down if the motor gets too hot.
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Likes TPayne and berkeman

FAQ: Determining motor/control options to act on a spring

How do you determine the appropriate motor for a spring-driven mechanism?

The appropriate motor for a spring-driven mechanism can be determined by considering the required torque, speed, and power for the specific application. It is important to also consider the weight and size of the mechanism, as well as any environmental factors that may affect the motor's performance.

What factors should be considered when selecting a control option for a spring-driven mechanism?

When selecting a control option for a spring-driven mechanism, factors such as the required precision, speed, and accuracy of the control, as well as the complexity and cost of the control system should be taken into account. It is also important to consider the compatibility of the control option with the chosen motor.

Can a spring-driven mechanism be controlled without a motor?

Yes, a spring-driven mechanism can be controlled without a motor by using manual controls such as levers, gears, or pulleys. However, this may not provide the same level of precision and automation as a motorized control option.

How do you calculate the required spring force for a specific mechanism?

The required spring force for a specific mechanism can be calculated by considering the weight of the load, the desired distance or angle of movement, and the mechanical advantage of the mechanism. This calculation can help determine the appropriate spring stiffness and size for the mechanism.

What are some common challenges when determining motor and control options for a spring-driven mechanism?

Some common challenges when determining motor and control options for a spring-driven mechanism include finding the right balance between power and speed, ensuring compatibility between the motor and control system, and accounting for any external factors that may affect the performance of the mechanism. It is also important to consider the cost and complexity of the chosen options and how they will impact the overall functionality of the mechanism.

Back
Top