Difference between the Shapiro Delay and time dilation?

  • I
  • Thread starter dsaun777
  • Start date
In summary, the Shapiro Delay refers to the phenomenon where the passage of light is delayed as it travels through a gravitational field, due to the curvature of spacetime described by general relativity. Time dilation, on the other hand, is the effect where time passes at different rates for observers in varying gravitational fields or relative velocities, as described by both special and general relativity. While both concepts involve the influence of gravity on time and light, the Shapiro Delay specifically concerns light's travel time in a gravitational field, whereas time dilation deals with the rate at which time elapses for different observers.
  • #1
dsaun777
296
39
I recently listened to The Origins Podcast with Lawrence Krauss and he had on the 94 year old physicist Irwin Shapiro. It was interesting and went into some of the details regarding the history of his work. In it he brings up how he first calculated what we now call the Shapiro Delay. It is a measure of light's deflection caused by a large mass such as the sun. It sounds very similar to time dilation. Does anyone here know the difference between the Shapiro Delay and time dilation and why it was only in 1964 that was discovered? It seems like a natural deduction from GR.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
It's more than just time dilation; it's measurably affected by the curvature of Schwarzschild spatial planes.

Why it wasn't thought of before is an imponderable. But there are a number of factors that may be relevant.

People tend to think in terms of tests you can do. To measure Shapiro delay you need to measure flight time, which depends on knowing the launch time of the light. The only ways I can think of doing it is radar (low power sets were developed in World War II), sending a space probe to the far side of the Sun (space exploration took off in the 1960s), or tracking pulsars (not discovered until the 1960s). It couldn't have been done much before it was. In fact, the radar set they tested it with was built in the early 60s, so may have stimulated research itself (people were looking for applications for it).

Also, I seem to recall that there was relatively little theoretical interest in GR between the 1920s and the 1960s, when there was a resurgence because new mathematical tools were brought to bear. So maybe there just wasn't much work in that field.
 
  • Like
Likes dsaun777 and Nugatory

FAQ: Difference between the Shapiro Delay and time dilation?

What is the Shapiro Delay?

The Shapiro Delay, also known as the gravitational time delay, occurs when light passes near a massive object and its travel time is increased due to the curvature of spacetime caused by the object's gravity. This effect was first predicted by Irwin Shapiro in 1964 and is a confirmation of General Relativity.

What is time dilation?

Time dilation is a phenomenon predicted by both Special and General Relativity, where time passes at different rates depending on the relative speed of observers (special relativity) or the strength of the gravitational field (general relativity). In special relativity, time slows down for objects moving at high speeds relative to an observer, while in general relativity, time slows down in stronger gravitational fields.

How do the Shapiro Delay and time dilation differ in their causes?

The Shapiro Delay is specifically caused by the curvature of spacetime due to a massive object's gravity affecting the path and travel time of light. Time dilation, on the other hand, can be caused by either relative velocity (special relativity) or gravitational fields (general relativity), affecting the passage of time itself for objects or observers.

Can the Shapiro Delay be observed in everyday life?

The Shapiro Delay is not something that can be observed in everyday life because it requires precise measurements of light passing near massive objects like stars or planets. It is typically observed in astronomical settings, such as when measuring the time delay of signals from spacecraft or the bending of light from distant stars around the Sun.

How do scientists measure the Shapiro Delay and time dilation?

Scientists measure the Shapiro Delay by sending signals, such as radar waves, to planets or spacecraft and measuring the extra time it takes for the signals to return when they pass near a massive object. Time dilation is measured using highly accurate atomic clocks, comparing the time elapsed on clocks moving at different velocities or in different gravitational fields, such as those on Earth's surface versus those in orbit.

Similar threads

Back
Top