Difficult problem in Rotational Mechanics JEE 2017 Comprehension paper

  • #1
physicsissohard
19
1
Homework Statement
One twirls a circular ring (of mass M and radius R) near the tip of one's finger as shown in Figure 1 In the process the finger never loses contact with the inner rim of the ring. The finger traces out the surface of a cone, shown by the dotted line. The radius of the path traced out by the point where the ring and the finger is in contact is r. The finger rotates with an angular velocity omega_o. The rotating ring rolls without slipping on the outside of a smaller circle described by the point where the ring and the finger is in contact (Figure-2). The coefficient of friction between the ring and the finger is u and the acceleration due to gravity is g
Relevant Equations
its down
This question is from the Jee Advanced 2017. This question stumped me because it was very difficult to do, the first part of the comprehension was asking for the kinetic energy of the ring.

This is what I mean.
Using the no-slip condition we can write ##\omega R-v_c=\omega_0r##. This is the no-slip condition. the relative velocity between the finger and the point of contact of the ring is ##0##. I assumed the angular velocity vector to be pointing out of the page and the finger to be moving in the counterclockwise direction, this is obvious through intuition.

Now if you draw fbd of the ring, you can come up with the equation ##N=\frac{mv^2}{x}##. Where ##N## is the normal force and ##x## is the distance between the center of mass and the IAOR(instantaneous axis of Rotation). the other equation is ##f=mg## and ##f=\mu N## where ##f## is the frictional force.

I don't know what to do with these how do they help solve the questions. This is the actual physics way to do it. All the other solutions on youtube and else where just assume by intuition(not obvious though) that the IAOR is at the center of the small circle, which basically sovles the question. Now I want proof of that, why is IAOR of this system the center of small ring. I came up with equations as shown as above but for some reason they aren't helping why?

I used the defining feature of the system to create equations, what did I miss.
Screenshot 2024-01-26 212303.png
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I presume ##v_c## is the instantaneous velocity of the centre of the ring. I find it more natural to express the ring's motion as the sum of a circular motion of its centre and its motion, rate ##\omega##, about that centre.
What are the radius and rate of the former and the radius of the latter?
 

Related to Difficult problem in Rotational Mechanics JEE 2017 Comprehension paper

What are the key concepts required to solve difficult problems in rotational mechanics for the JEE 2017 comprehension paper?

Key concepts include torque, angular momentum, moment of inertia, rotational kinematics, and the parallel axis theorem. A strong understanding of Newton's laws as applied to rotational motion and the ability to relate linear and angular quantities are also crucial.

How do you approach a problem involving the calculation of moment of inertia in complex systems?

To calculate the moment of inertia in complex systems, break down the system into simpler components whose moments of inertia are known or easier to calculate. Use the parallel axis theorem to shift axes when necessary, and then sum the moments of inertia of individual components to get the total moment of inertia.

What strategies can be used to solve problems involving angular momentum conservation?

Identify the system and isolate it from external torques. Use the conservation of angular momentum principle, which states that if no external torque acts on a system, its total angular momentum remains constant. Set up the initial and final angular momentum equations and solve for the unknowns.

How do you handle problems that involve both rotational and translational motion?

For problems involving both rotational and translational motion, use the concept of rolling without slipping, which relates linear velocity and angular velocity through the equation v = ωr. Apply Newton's second law for both translational and rotational motion, and solve the resulting system of equations simultaneously.

What common mistakes should be avoided when solving rotational mechanics problems in the JEE comprehension paper?

Common mistakes include neglecting the contribution of all forces and torques, misapplying the parallel axis theorem, confusing angular quantities with their linear counterparts, and failing to account for energy conservation principles. Always double-check units and ensure that all physical quantities are consistent.

Back
Top