Dirac equation for proton/neutron

In summary, there have been attempts to incorporate the possibility of a proton transforming into a neutron into Dirac's equation, but these theories have proven to be non-renormalizable. Instead, the use of QCD based on quarks and gluons is necessary. However, this transformation requires the use of electro-weak theory due to the change in flavors. It is debated whether non-renormalizability is a characteristic of all effective field theories or not.
  • #1
paweld
255
0
Is it possible to incorporate into Dirac equation for proton
the possibility of its transformation into neutron (isospin freedom)?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
paweld said:
Is it possible to incorporate into Dirac equation for proton
the possibility of its transformation into neutron (isospin freedom)?
There were attempts to formulate (effective) nucleon theories, but all these theories turned out to be non-renormalizable. One must use QCD based on quarks and gluons instead. But turning a proton into a neutron (an u- into a d-quark) requires electro-weak theory as only W-bosons change flavours.
 
  • #3
Tom,

I was thinking about this question and found this older post.
Isn't non-renormalisability quasi a charateristic of any effective field theory?
Of course we expect divergences when the energy becomes comparable to the binding energy of the quarks, but this does not mean that effective field theories for the proton might not be usefull at low energies.
 
  • #4
DrDu said:
Isn't non-renormalisability quasi a charateristic of any effective field theory?
I am not so sure about that; non-renormalizability is acceptable (not acceptable) for effective theories (fundamental theories); but uis it necessary the case that effective theories must be non-renormalizable? or let's ask the other way round: what would it mean to have a renormalizable effective theory?
 

FAQ: Dirac equation for proton/neutron

What is the Dirac equation for a proton/neutron?

The Dirac equation for a proton/neutron is a relativistic wave equation that describes the behavior of these particles. It was developed by physicist Paul Dirac in the 1920s and combines the principles of special relativity and quantum mechanics.

How does the Dirac equation differ from the Schrödinger equation?

The Dirac equation takes into account the spin of particles, whereas the Schrödinger equation does not. It also accounts for the effects of special relativity, making it applicable to high-speed particles.

What is the significance of the Dirac equation in particle physics?

The Dirac equation is a fundamental equation in particle physics, as it accurately describes the behavior of fermions (particles with half-integer spin) such as protons and neutrons. It is also used in the study of quantum field theory and has been instrumental in the development of the standard model of particle physics.

Can the Dirac equation be used to predict the properties of protons/neutrons?

While the Dirac equation provides a mathematical description of the behavior of protons and neutrons, it cannot be used alone to predict their properties such as mass and charge. These values must be experimentally measured and then incorporated into the equation to make accurate predictions.

Is the Dirac equation applicable to other particles besides protons and neutrons?

Yes, the Dirac equation can be applied to other fermionic particles such as electrons, quarks, and neutrinos. It is also used in the study of antimatter and has been successfully used to predict the existence of the positron, the antiparticle of the electron.

Back
Top