Do increased windings conflict with thicker coil diameter?

In summary, there are three different factors that can affect the motor magnetism and efficiency: increasing the number of windings, increasing the cross section of the rotor, and increasing the coil diameter of the wire used for winding. These factors can sometimes seem conflicting, as increasing one may decrease another. However, it is important to consider the trade-offs and find the right balance for optimal motor performance.
  • #1
ChineseSmeagol
2
0
I have read that to increase motor magnetism that an increase in the windings increases the number of tiny magnets that can be used to provide the magnetic force. I have also read that increasing the cross section of the rotor increases the efficiency. Finally I have read that increasing the coil diameter of the wire used for winding increases the efficiency of the motor.

These sound somewhat conflicting to me. If one increases the number of windings but also chooses to make the motor larger and the coil thicker isn't the magnetism decreased because of A) increased resistance to the current because more windings creates a longer path, B) a larger cross section reduces the magnetic aggregation, and C) the coil diameter of the wire makes the motor a lot more heavier and thus more initial load losses?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
ChineseSmeagol said:
A) increased resistance to the current because more windings creates a longer path
You have an increased resistance but you need a smaller current for the same magnetic field (and even smaller for the same product of magnetic field and area),
ChineseSmeagol said:
C) the coil diameter of the wire makes the motor a lot more heavier and thus more initial load losses?
That is true. If you want to change the speed frequently, a smaller motor is better.
 

Related to Do increased windings conflict with thicker coil diameter?

1. What is the relationship between increased windings and thicker coil diameter?

The increased number of windings in a coil and thicker coil diameter are directly related. As the number of windings increases, the diameter of the coil also increases. This is because more wire is needed to create the additional windings, resulting in a thicker coil.

2. What effect does increased windings have on the performance of a coil?

Increased windings generally result in a stronger magnetic field and higher inductance, which can improve the performance of a coil. However, it can also lead to a larger physical size and higher resistance, which may affect the overall efficiency of the coil.

3. Can increased windings and thicker coil diameter create any conflicts?

Yes, there can be conflicts when increasing both windings and coil diameter. As mentioned earlier, this can lead to a larger physical size and higher resistance, which may not be ideal for certain applications. Additionally, the increased number of windings can also cause the coil to overheat, which can potentially damage the coil or other components.

4. How do increased windings and thicker coil diameter affect the cost of a coil?

Increasing the number of windings and coil diameter can result in a higher cost for a coil. This is because more materials and labor are required to create the additional windings and larger coil diameter. However, the cost may vary depending on the specific materials used and the manufacturer.

5. Is there an optimal ratio between increased windings and coil diameter?

The optimal ratio between increased windings and coil diameter can vary depending on the specific application and requirements. In some cases, a higher number of windings may be preferred, while in others a larger coil diameter may be more beneficial. It is important to consider the trade-offs and consult with a knowledgeable expert when determining the optimal ratio for a specific coil design.

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
69
Views
11K
Replies
17
Views
522
Replies
12
Views
5K
Replies
16
Views
2K
Replies
17
Views
3K
Back
Top