Do Leading Scientists' Beliefs on God Influence Society's Views?

  • Thread starter BlackVision
  • Start date
In summary: This is a valid point and one that I hadn't considered. However, I think it would be reasonable to assume that if a scientist believes in a god then they would also believe that this god is still involved in the universe and has a hand in it.
  • #36
Loren Booda said:
BlackVision. However, they have yet to consistantly and honestly disprove the existence of God, even within their own community. Also, might the NAS leadership when tapping is members encourage tacitly skepticism (a fundamental attitude for scientists) of God?
The burden of proof would not be on the atheist. It is on the one making the claim. It would be similar to someone stating "there is an invisible ghost in my room that likes to drink beer all day long and watch his invisible tv" and asking you to disprove it.

The reason why most scientists are atheists is because it is incompatible with the scientific approach. The necessity of relying on evidence. When the scientific method is applied, the conclusion cannot result in "there is indeed a god" or even "there is ample evidence to consider this a valid scientific theory"
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #37
So only because "leading scientists" reject God, that means that everybody else who are presumably "ignorant" and bound to the beliefs of scientists have to reject God as well..? Ask yourself.
 
  • #38
I think we should do a little experiment. Raise an entire generation of children without religion. Given that we no longer have a problem with explanatory gaps in everyday phenomena, I wonder if they would ever postulate any kind of supernatural explanation for anything. In other words, if mankind had had the knowledge of natural processes that we have today in the beginning, would the ideas of gods and spirits and such ever have been developed?
 
  • #39
So only because "leading scientists" reject God, that means that everybody else who are presumably "ignorant" and bound to the beliefs of scientists have to reject God as well..? Ask yourself.


I don't think that was ever implied by the original poster. It was simply a statement of a fact. You seem to read too much into it when you jokingly assume that anyone else who is not a leading scientist is ignorant. I think you truly need to "Ask yourself", are your unfounded beliefs tying down your thinking?
 

Similar threads

Replies
120
Views
12K
Back
Top