Do photons interact with gravitons?

In summary, QED (as presented in textbooks) is formulated in flat space, disregarding gravity, but it can be included through minimal coupling to each particle species, including photons. While gravity is not yet part of the Standard Model of particle physics, we have experimental evidence that light couples to geometry and there are attempts to quantize electrodynamics of classical, curved spacetime. However, quantizing gravity using entities like gravitons becomes meaningless and must be replaced by something else.
  • #1
jaydnul
558
15
Does QED predict that the hypothetical graviton particle will interact with light? I mean it would have to interact in some way, right? We already have evidence that it does. (Eddington and such). I was just under the impression that the graviton needs some sort of mass to interact with.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The graviton needs energy to interact with, and photons have energy, so, yes, photons interact with gravitons.

QED (as presented in textbooks) is formulated in flat space, disregarding gravity. But gravity can be included in a straightforward way, with so called "minimal coupling" to each particle species, including photons.
 
  • #3
Does QED predict that the hypothetical graviton particle will interact with light?

no
I mean it would have to interact in some way, right?

yes
We already have evidence that it does. (Eddington and such).

yes

I was just under the impression that the graviton needs some sort of mass to interact with.

already answered: gravity arises from, mass, energy, even pressure.

Gravity is not yet part of the Standard Model [SM] of particle physics. Relativistic QED of the SM explains how matter and photons interact in flat spacetime.
 
  • #4
There are a couple of related questions.

First we know (experimentally) that light couples to geometry (gravitational and cosmological red shift, bending of light rays). Then we know (theoretically) how classical electrodynamics can be coupled to gravity; please refer to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell's_equations_in_curved_spacetime.

Regarding quantization it becomes rather difficult. There are two steps: i) quantize electrodynamics of classical, curved spacetime; ii) quantize gravity, too.

Regarding i) I am no expert, but there are a couple of well-known results, the most famous one is Hawking radiation which shows how spacetime geometry affects the QFT vacuum. Unfortunately all papers I known do not discuss this effect using photons but massless scalar particles b/c math is much simpler and b/c the expectation is that the main results are not invalidated when going from spin 0 to spin 1. But honestly, I expect severe difficulties in gauge fixing for non-trivial geometries, and even more problems for renormalization.

Regarding ii) this is related to the problem of quantum gravity which us purely understood even w/o taking other fields into account. But as far as I can see nearly all research programs - ignoring string theory and supergravity for a moment - indicate that what we would call a graviton (a quantized plane or distorted wave on a classical background geometry) is not the right entity to be used for quantization of gravity. The basic physical reason is that this approach breaks down when going into the deep quantum gravity regime where this split into classical spacetime + quantum fluctuations becomes meaningless as the latter one must not leave the classical geometry unaffected.

So my conclusion is that a) yes, quantum d.o.f. of the el.-mag. and the gravitational field do interact (and we already see this on the classical level) but that b) using entities like gravitons becomes meaningless and must be replaced by something else.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes 1 person

FAQ: Do photons interact with gravitons?

Do photons experience gravitational force?

Yes, photons do experience gravitational force. According to Einstein's theory of general relativity, any object with mass or energy, including photons, can be affected by gravity. This means that photons can be influenced by the gravitational pull of massive objects, such as stars and planets.

Can photons interact with gravitons?

While it is currently a topic of debate in the scientific community, it is generally believed that photons do not interact with gravitons. Gravitons are hypothetical particles that are thought to mediate the force of gravity, but since photons have no mass, it is unlikely that they interact with gravitons.

What is the relationship between photons and gravitons?

Photons and gravitons are both fundamental particles in the Standard Model of particle physics. However, they are believed to interact differently with other particles and forces. Photons are associated with the electromagnetic force, while gravitons are associated with the gravitational force.

How does the interaction between photons and gravitons affect the behavior of light?

The interaction between photons and gravitons does not have a significant effect on the behavior of light. This is because the gravitational force is incredibly weak compared to the electromagnetic force, and photons do not interact with gravitons.

Can photons be used to detect gravitons?

No, photons cannot be used to directly detect gravitons. Gravitons are theoretical particles, and there is currently no experimental evidence for their existence. However, scientists are actively researching ways to indirectly detect gravitons through their effects on other particles and forces.

Similar threads

Back
Top