Does an Elliptic Orbit's Speed Depend on Its Semi-Major Axis?

  • Thread starter fahd
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation is about a question involving a particle in an elliptic orbit under the influence of a central force. The question asks to prove a relationship between the maximum and minimum speeds of the particle and the semi major axis and period of its motion. One person suggests that the semi minor axis should be used instead, and the other person agrees but asks for help. The solution involves using equations to calculate the area of the ellipse and substituting it into the given equation to find the correct answer.
  • #1
fahd
40
0
hi
i have this question to do which says..

*)A particle moves in a elliptic orbit under the influence of a central force F= -k/r^2.Prove that the product of the maximim and minimum speeds is equal to [2 pi a/t]^2 where 'a' is the semi major axis of the ellipse and 't' is the period of its motion..

Dont u think it should be the semi minor axis 'b' instead of the semi major axis 'a'..in the question..because I am getting the former as the right answer..
please help!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
wow. i have the exact same problem.
you can express the 'right answer' in terms of b
[tex] ( \frac{2 \pi a} { \tau } )^2 [/tex] eqs 1
recall:
[tex] \tau = \frac{2 A} {l} [/tex] eqs 2
where A is the area of an ellipse and is given by ╥ab
substituting 2 into 1 gives:
[tex] ( \frac{2 \pi a} { \tau } )^2 = \frac{l^2} {b^2} [/tex]
 

FAQ: Does an Elliptic Orbit's Speed Depend on Its Semi-Major Axis?

1. Is this question grammatically correct?

The answer to this question depends on the specific question being asked. In general, a question should follow the same rules of grammar as a statement, with a subject, verb, and complete thought. If you are unsure about the grammar of your question, it may be helpful to rephrase it or consult a grammar guide.

2. Is this question relevant to the topic?

This is a subjective question and can only be answered by the person asking it. However, if you are asking a question in a specific context, it is important to make sure that it relates to the topic at hand. If you are unsure, you can ask for clarification or do some research to better understand the topic.

3. Is this question too broad or too narrow?

Again, this is a subjective question and can only be answered by the person asking it. However, a good question should be specific enough to get a clear answer, but broad enough to allow for a thorough response. If you are unsure, you can ask for feedback from others or do some additional research to refine your question.

4. Is this question clear and concise?

A good question should be easy to understand and not use unnecessarily complicated language. If you find yourself using complex words or phrases, it may be helpful to simplify your question. Additionally, try to keep your question brief and to the point to avoid confusion.

5. Is this question answerable?

This is an important question to consider when asking any question. A good question should have a clear and specific answer. If your question is too vague or open-ended, it may be difficult to provide a satisfactory response. Try to make sure your question has a clear objective and can be answered with information or evidence.

Back
Top