Does Time Exist Without Perception or External Cues?

  • Thread starter Phy6explorer
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Observer
In summary: So, in summary, the conversation discusses the concept of time for a man who is completely frozen and not sensing anything, but his internal organs are still working. It is debated whether he would experience time or not, with the conclusion that time is perceived differently while sleeping and can be influenced by external factors. The conversation also mentions the idea of a biological clock and its role in keeping track of time.
  • #1
Phy6explorer
109
0
Just imagine, a man who has been frozen completely, cannot move, does not sense, but he is alive and his internal organs are working perfectly. What is time for him? I mean, he is not sensing anything he is not sensing his living nor anything that is going around him?
So, time doesn't exist for him does it?Isn't time something that man has assumed to keep track of happenings or events around him?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
if his internal organs are working to keep him alive, that's motion. So then his organs should be experiencing time. Maybe his frozen outer body would not experience a normal aging process but i think his internal organs would.

Its normal to not experience time while sleeping and the body is at complete rest, but that timeless experience due to an abnormal sense of memory while sleeping. All the while, despite that sleep makes you look better, your still aging while you sleep. Another interesting fact I've heard is that the more you sleep the longer you might live. I don't think this has anything to due with time, but everything to do with sleep being a natural body re-fueler.
 
  • #3
Well, I've been hearing all the time that the more you sleep the lesser you will live! Well that's from my mother because I sleep a lot. But living is nothing but experiencing time isn't it and if you are sleeping you do not experience time.So how can you say that?My mother is right after all...
 
  • #4
If he is conscience, i.e... can still think and not asleep, then absolutely he will experience time. The brain has a specialized group of neurons that act as a very precise internal 'clock', but its really more like a metronome.
 
  • #5
Are those specialised group of neurons the reason why we get up from bed and say " I slept a lot"
 
  • #6
Sleeping is a different circumstance all together. While asleep your brain behaves very differently than while awake, in ways that we certainly don't fully understand. However, if you were blind and deaf and locked in an environment that never changes, you could still perceive time. Granted, you must remember that it is much more like a metronome then a clock.
 
  • #7
But do you think,if I am locked up in a small, pitch dark room with no light nor clock or watch and I stay awake for around four days, food and water coming through a cat-flap kind of thing, my specialised group of neutrons will get confused and my senses of time will become sort of unusual. Do you think my ideas about day and night will change??
 
  • #8
dude, just smoke some bud, or take some amphetamines, depending on how you want to change the rate of time
 
  • #9
This a reply that should have been given to a similar question in the biology section, not here!:rolleyes:
 
  • #10
Phy6explorer said:
But do you think,if I am locked up in a small, pitch dark room with no light nor clock or watch and I stay awake for around four days, food and water coming through a cat-flap kind of thing, my specialised group of neutrons will get confused and my senses of time will become sort of unusual. Do you think my ideas about day and night will change??

Absolutely you will be confused as to night and day, but your body will eventually go into a 25 hour sleep cycle regardless of what time it is outside ( Google: MICHEL SIFFRE). My point being yes we have an internal biological clock type mechanism, but no it does not keep track of things like day/night or time of year without external influence, only say seconds and hours.
 

FAQ: Does Time Exist Without Perception or External Cues?

What is meant by "Time-A factor of the observer?"

Time-A factor of the observer refers to the concept that our perception of time is subjective and can be influenced by various factors such as our age, culture, and personal experiences.

How does the observer affect our perception of time?

The observer's perception of time can be influenced by their level of attention, emotional state, and level of engagement in an activity. For example, time may seem to pass quickly when we are focused and enjoying ourselves, but it can feel slow when we are bored or anxious.

Is time a physical or psychological phenomenon?

Time is both a physical and psychological phenomenon. Physically, time can be measured and observed through the movement of objects and changes in the natural world. Psychologically, our perception of time can be influenced by our thoughts, emotions, and experiences.

Can time be manipulated by the observer?

While time itself cannot be manipulated, our perception of it can be influenced by the observer's thoughts, emotions, and actions. For example, engaging in activities that we enjoy can make time seem to pass faster, while being in a state of boredom can make it seem slower.

How does the concept of time as a factor of the observer relate to the theory of relativity?

The theory of relativity states that time is relative and can be affected by factors such as gravity and velocity. This aligns with the concept of time as a factor of the observer, as our perception of time can also be influenced by external factors and is not a fixed, universal concept.

Similar threads

Replies
24
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
21
Views
5K
Replies
18
Views
7K
Replies
11
Views
3K
Back
Top