Equivalent Statements: An Example

  • Thread starter samp
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Identity
In summary, the conversation discusses the statement A if and only if B, and it is clarified that this does not necessarily mean that A and B are identical. The speaker requests a concrete example to understand this concept better. An example is provided, stating that the two statements are equivalent but cannot be considered equal in the traditional sense.
  • #1
samp
15
0
Suppose we have a statement A that holds if and only if statement B holds.

"A if and only if B"

I'm fairly sure I read before that this does not necessarily mean that A and B are identical: in general, A <--> B does not imply A = B.

I'm having difficulty determining how A and B could be distinguished from each other - besides, of course, their names.

I think that a simple, concrete example would clear this up for me; if someone could provide one I'd greatly appreciate it. My sanity's been really wearing thin, lately (just have a look at my other thread; actually, don't)... maybe I should lay off the Red Bulls.
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
  • #2
_Equality_ of logical statements doesn't really make sense. But if you still want an example:

Let n be an integer, then n is even if and only if n^2 is even.

It doesn't make sense to say (n is even) equals (n^2 is even), unless you wish to define what you mean by 'equal'. The two statements are equivalent, in the obvious sense.
 

FAQ: Equivalent Statements: An Example

What is the difference between biconditional and identity?

Biconditional is a logical operator that is represented by the symbol "↔" and means "if and only if". It is used to connect two statements where both must be either true or false. Identity, on the other hand, is a statement that is always true, such as "a = a". It is not a logical operator, but rather a statement of equality.

When should I use biconditional versus identity in my research?

Biconditional is typically used when discussing logical statements or conditional relationships, while identity is more commonly used in mathematics and equations. The choice of which to use depends on the context and purpose of your research.

Can biconditional and identity be used interchangeably?

No, biconditional and identity have different meanings and cannot be used interchangeably. Biconditional connects two statements, while identity is a statement itself.

How do I represent biconditional and identity in symbolic logic?

Biconditional is represented by the symbol "↔" and identity is represented by the symbol "=" in symbolic logic.

Are there any real-life examples of biconditional and identity?

Yes, there are many examples of biconditional and identity in real life. For example, the statement "A person is a student if and only if they are enrolled in a university" is a biconditional statement. The statement "1 + 1 = 2" is an identity statement.

Similar threads

Back
Top