- #1
3mpathy
- 79
- 0
please, i need input
this is my first post in this forum, so hello everyone.
i'd like to say that i have never really had experience in philosophy so if anyone recognizes my thoughts as someone elses theory then please tell me so i can look into it.now to the real stuff. I would reallllllllly apprecaite some advice/wisdom about the topic(s) listed below.Sorry that all of this is jumbled together. (Right now I am trying to find answers and I have a lot of questions)
i was thinking the other day(suprise) and for some strange reason i thought about a quote that Einstien said a lot "God doesn't throw dice!" and i began to think about wut he meant when he said that. To me it seems that all of this talk about the universe being random and that chemical and quantum reactions are random events seems odd to me. To me it seems logical to assume that if u had the EXACT same senario( I am talking the SAME EXACT ONE!) that it would give u the EXACT same output. {please correct me if I am wrong with my assumption} Also the human brain is made out of atoms and what not. So if that is true then if u have the exact same input to the human brain then would not get the exact same output? if u over simplfy it then u get chemical reactions. so is there a "random generator" in the brain anywhere?
or is it that the brain ,like an atom, just does certain designated tasks? if this is so then what is creativity? Is that just applying a perspective that some else hasnt seen onto a object? Most people would say that it is coming up with new ideas, but ideas come from the brain and the brain is just a input orientated device. So following that logic, does creativity even exist?
What happens if you applied those thoughts to fate? my chain of logic is that if there is only 1 exact output for 1 exact input then doesn't that prove the absence of free will? Or do you want to get into string theory and the possiblities that is a "dimension" for every possible out/input. But if you assume that we are in 1 "dimension" then wouldn't that mean that there is only 1 output for everything?
So to try and summarize all that i am asking, here is a list:
1)Have you heard this chain of reasoning before? If so where?
2)Can the human brain be over simplfied as a machine that just uses in/outputs
3)Is there a "random generator" in humans?
4)Do you think that MY chain of logic (proves/ doesn't do anything) to the argument of freewill/no freewill? (that question is to big for me to comprehend right now so I would like you to limit your response on this question so that it relates to my chain of reasoning. That way I can break it into little peices that I have a chance on understanding)
thank you for ur trying to help me understand things (lol sry if i wasted your time)
this is my first post in this forum, so hello everyone.
i was thinking the other day(suprise) and for some strange reason i thought about a quote that Einstien said a lot "God doesn't throw dice!" and i began to think about wut he meant when he said that. To me it seems that all of this talk about the universe being random and that chemical and quantum reactions are random events seems odd to me. To me it seems logical to assume that if u had the EXACT same senario( I am talking the SAME EXACT ONE!) that it would give u the EXACT same output. {please correct me if I am wrong with my assumption} Also the human brain is made out of atoms and what not. So if that is true then if u have the exact same input to the human brain then would not get the exact same output? if u over simplfy it then u get chemical reactions. so is there a "random generator" in the brain anywhere?
![Bug Eye :bugeye: :bugeye:](https://www.physicsforums.com/styles/physicsforums/xenforo/smilies/oldschool/bugeye.gif)
What happens if you applied those thoughts to fate? my chain of logic is that if there is only 1 exact output for 1 exact input then doesn't that prove the absence of free will? Or do you want to get into string theory and the possiblities that is a "dimension" for every possible out/input. But if you assume that we are in 1 "dimension" then wouldn't that mean that there is only 1 output for everything?
So to try and summarize all that i am asking, here is a list:
1)Have you heard this chain of reasoning before? If so where?
2)Can the human brain be over simplfied as a machine that just uses in/outputs
3)Is there a "random generator" in humans?
4)Do you think that MY chain of logic (proves/ doesn't do anything) to the argument of freewill/no freewill? (that question is to big for me to comprehend right now so I would like you to limit your response on this question so that it relates to my chain of reasoning. That way I can break it into little peices that I have a chance on understanding)
thank you for ur trying to help me understand things (lol sry if i wasted your time)