General question about dimensional analysis

In summary, the conversation discusses a problem related to acceleration having a certain magnitude and the dimensions of a variable involved in the problem. The problem statement is clarified and the correct interpretation of the dimensions is provided. The concept of inverse meters is also discussed and its meaning is left for the listener to determine.
  • #1
V0ODO0CH1LD
278
0
I am actually going to post the problem that sparked the question I am about to ask, but I don't need help with the answer and that's why I didn't start this thread in the homework and coursework section. Actually, I just realized I read the problem statement in the wrong way, which makes my question pointless with regards to the problem. Anyway, I am still wondering about it independently of weather it helps with the problem or not. So here it it:

The problem stated that an acceleration has magnitude [itex] \mu(r+\frac{a^3}{r^2}) [/itex], where [itex] a [/itex] is the initial displacement and [itex] r [/itex] is the distance from the origin. What the problem asked was to check what were the dimensions of [itex] \mu [/itex]. When you read it right it's an easy problem, right?

But in the way I had originally read it, it stated: an acceleration has magnitude [itex] \mu(\frac{r + a^3}{r^2}) [/itex]. Which makes the thing inside the parenthesis look like [itex] \mu(\frac{1}{r}+\frac{a^3}{r^2}) [/itex].

Well, [itex]\frac{a^3}{r^2}[/itex] would just be something like [itex]\frac{(am)^3}{(rm)^2}[/itex], where [itex] m [/itex] is some unit of distance and that would simplify to [itex]\frac{a^3}{r^2}m[/itex]. Which is fine.

But what would [itex]\frac{1}{rm}[/itex] mean? Like, a dimensionless something per unit of distance? How should I think about [itex]\frac{1}{r}m^{-1}[/itex]? Or does it not even exist on the account that I read the problem wrong? At first I was like: well; I have something like 1/r inverse meters, so that must mean I have r regular meters.. But that makes no sense. Is there a correct way to view this?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I believe you are overthinking. I assume μ(r+a3/r2) is correct. You state that r and a are distances, so μ has dimension 1/distance x distance/time2, so that μ has dimension 1/time2.
 
  • #3
mathman said:
I believe you are overthinking.2.

Sorry, I tend to do that..

I understood the problem after reading the problem statement correctly, but it still got me wondering what (meter)-1 means. Not any other unit over meters, just inverse meters. What does it mean if I say 3m-1? Is it undefined?
 
  • #4
Depends on the context. The wavenumber of a wave has units of m^-1; that is, the number of wavelengths per unit distance.
 
  • #5
The meaning is left for you to decide/discover, but whatever you find must reconcile with the fact that there are three of them per metre.

It might be three full wavelengths of EM radiation per metre, and you'd be specifying light in the UHF frequency band, or it might refer to the linear density of turtles as they follow a one-dimensional path towards the sea.

Whatever it is, there are three of them in a metre.
 

FAQ: General question about dimensional analysis

What is dimensional analysis?

Dimensional analysis is a mathematical tool used in science to convert units, compare different quantities, and check the consistency of equations. It involves analyzing and manipulating the units of physical quantities to ensure their compatibility.

Why is dimensional analysis important in science?

Dimensional analysis is important in science because it allows for a systematic and efficient way to convert units, check the correctness of equations, and identify errors. It also helps scientists to understand the relationships between different physical quantities in a given system.

How is dimensional analysis used in calculations?

Dimensional analysis is used in calculations by setting up a conversion factor between two units and canceling out the common units to obtain the desired unit. This ensures that the final result is in the correct unit and also helps to identify any errors in the calculation.

Can dimensional analysis be used in all fields of science?

Yes, dimensional analysis can be used in all fields of science, including physics, chemistry, biology, and engineering. It is a fundamental tool that helps to ensure the accuracy and consistency of measurements and calculations in all scientific disciplines.

Are there any limitations to dimensional analysis?

One limitation of dimensional analysis is that it only works for physical quantities that can be expressed in terms of base units, such as length, mass, and time. It cannot be applied to non-physical quantities, such as emotions or thoughts. Additionally, dimensional analysis assumes that all variables are independent, which may not always be the case.

Similar threads

Replies
13
Views
662
Replies
6
Views
874
Replies
19
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
116
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
24
Views
639
Back
Top