Hello, world

[Ivan Nikiforov]

How did you find PF?

Yandex Search

Hello! My name is Ivan Nikiforov. I am an engineer in automated control systems. I have a development in the field of electrical engineering. I would like to talk about her on the forum.

 

[berkeman]

Welcome to PF, Ivan.

 

[phinds]

I have a development in the field of electrical engineering. I would like to talk about her on the forum.

Be sure to read the rules. If your idea involves any new theory, it would likely be a problem.

 

[Ivan Nikiforov]

The name of the development is "Technology for generating electrical energy using an intermediate reference frame."The technology is based on the principle of relativity of simultaneity of A. Einstein's special theory of relativity. I'm sorry, I don't speak English. I use a translator. Could this be an obstacle?

 

[Ivan Nikiforov]

The annotation is in the attachment. There may be a mistake in my results. I wanted to talk about it, consult and understand.

 

[phinds]

I did not read the whole articel, but it start off VERY badly by saying

The article presents the theoretical and experimental results of a study aimed at creating a technology for generating electrical energy using an intermediate reference frame.

It is possible that this is do to a translation problem, but changing your frame of reference does NOT produce any physical changes.

 

[Ivan Nikiforov]

If you move the conductor in a magnetic field, then the Ampere force acts on it, which creates resistance to the primary motor. If you move an external circuit that is not in a magnetic field, the Ampere force does not act on it and therefore there is no resistance to the primary motor. Is that correct?

 

[phinds]

Whether it is correct or not, it has nothing to do with changing reference frames, which is what I was objecting to. You are talking about something completely different.

 

[Ivan Nikiforov]

I agree that changing the frame of reference does not lead to any physical changes. But the reference frames are in different conditions. The reference frame of the conductor is in a magnetic field, and the reference frame of the external circuit is not in a magnetic field. To obtain an electromotive force, a conductor can be moved in a magnetic field relative to an external circuit, or an external circuit can be moved relative to a conductor in a magnetic field.

 

[phinds]

OK, I went back and gave the article another look. Again, I did not read the whole thing, BUT ... what I did see was that the author has some totally ridiculous statements about "moving reference frames" that has nothing to do with what he is describing. In fact, there is absolutely no need for him to bring in reference frames at all. He should JUST be talking about the relative motion of physical objects.

His lack of understanding about the proper use of "reference frames" makes me concerned in that, I can't help but think, if he got that wrong, what else did he get wrong.

It IS possible that the paper is perfectly fine (or maybe not) if he would just leave out all mentions of reference frames.

 

[berkeman]

Thread is closed for Mentor review...