- #1
space-time
- 218
- 4
As some may know, I have been studying the Morris-Thorne wormhole metric for quite some time now.
ds2= -c2dt2 + dl2 + (b2 + l2)(dθ2 + sin2(θ)d∅2)
Now, from this space-time interval, it is easy to see how I would deduce the following metric tensor:
g00= -1
g11 = 1
g22= (b2 + l2)
g33= (b2 + l2)sin2(θ)
where
x0 = ct
x1= l
x2= θ
x3= ∅
Now with this metric tensor, the Christoffel symbols yield:
Γ122= - L
Γ133= - Lsin2(θ)
Γ212 and its counterpart with the lower indices reversed (Γ221) = L/(b2 + l2)
Γ233 = - sin(θ)cos(θ)
Γ313 and its counterpart = L/(b2 + l2)
Γ323 and its counterpart= cot(θ)
If you plug these Christoffel symbols into the Riemann tensor formula:
Rabmv = (∂Γavb/ ∂xm) - (∂Γamb/ ∂xv) + ΓamcΓcvb - ΓavcΓcmb
you will see that the following Riemann tensor elements equal as follows (I am doing these specific elements for a certain reason):
R2323 = (b2sin2(θ))/(b2 + l2)
R0323 , R1323 and R3323 = 0
Now, I did these specific elements for the purpose of calculating the purely covariant version of the Riemann tensor element R2323 using the formula:
R2323 = g2fRf323
Doing this yields the following result:
R2323= b2sin2(θ)
The following sources however, (http://www.spacetimetravel.org/wurmlochflug/wurmlochflug.html) (http://www.physics.uofl.edu/wkomp/teaching/spring2006/589/final/wormholes.pdf ) (pg. 4 on the PDF) said that Rθ∅θ∅ (which is in fact R2323) = b2/ (b2 + l2)2
This is the part that I do not understand. I have shown you clearly with the use of formulas how I derived
R2323= b2sin2(θ)
They however, did not show any work on how they got
R2323 = b2/ (b2 + l2)2
Can anyone please tell me how they got that (starting with the metric tensor in matrix form and going forward)?
I know that they worked in an orthonormal basis. My problem with that is this: I know what a basis is and I know what an orthonormal basis is. I know what basis vectors are and I know (or at least I think I know) how to derive basis vectors using a metric tensor. What I do not know, is what to do with said basis vectors after I have derived them or how to take a tensor product (despite the fact that I know what one is).
Essentially, I don't know how you convert from a coordinate basis to orthonormal with regards to these tensors (like the Riemann).
That is why I ask if someone can please tell me what they did differently in the beginning of their calculations to get:
R2323 = b2/ (b2 + l2)2
instead of
R2323= b2sin2(θ)
ds2= -c2dt2 + dl2 + (b2 + l2)(dθ2 + sin2(θ)d∅2)
Now, from this space-time interval, it is easy to see how I would deduce the following metric tensor:
g00= -1
g11 = 1
g22= (b2 + l2)
g33= (b2 + l2)sin2(θ)
where
x0 = ct
x1= l
x2= θ
x3= ∅
Now with this metric tensor, the Christoffel symbols yield:
Γ122= - L
Γ133= - Lsin2(θ)
Γ212 and its counterpart with the lower indices reversed (Γ221) = L/(b2 + l2)
Γ233 = - sin(θ)cos(θ)
Γ313 and its counterpart = L/(b2 + l2)
Γ323 and its counterpart= cot(θ)
If you plug these Christoffel symbols into the Riemann tensor formula:
Rabmv = (∂Γavb/ ∂xm) - (∂Γamb/ ∂xv) + ΓamcΓcvb - ΓavcΓcmb
you will see that the following Riemann tensor elements equal as follows (I am doing these specific elements for a certain reason):
R2323 = (b2sin2(θ))/(b2 + l2)
R0323 , R1323 and R3323 = 0
Now, I did these specific elements for the purpose of calculating the purely covariant version of the Riemann tensor element R2323 using the formula:
R2323 = g2fRf323
Doing this yields the following result:
R2323= b2sin2(θ)
The following sources however, (http://www.spacetimetravel.org/wurmlochflug/wurmlochflug.html) (http://www.physics.uofl.edu/wkomp/teaching/spring2006/589/final/wormholes.pdf ) (pg. 4 on the PDF) said that Rθ∅θ∅ (which is in fact R2323) = b2/ (b2 + l2)2
This is the part that I do not understand. I have shown you clearly with the use of formulas how I derived
R2323= b2sin2(θ)
They however, did not show any work on how they got
R2323 = b2/ (b2 + l2)2
Can anyone please tell me how they got that (starting with the metric tensor in matrix form and going forward)?
I know that they worked in an orthonormal basis. My problem with that is this: I know what a basis is and I know what an orthonormal basis is. I know what basis vectors are and I know (or at least I think I know) how to derive basis vectors using a metric tensor. What I do not know, is what to do with said basis vectors after I have derived them or how to take a tensor product (despite the fact that I know what one is).
Essentially, I don't know how you convert from a coordinate basis to orthonormal with regards to these tensors (like the Riemann).
That is why I ask if someone can please tell me what they did differently in the beginning of their calculations to get:
R2323 = b2/ (b2 + l2)2
instead of
R2323= b2sin2(θ)
Last edited by a moderator: