How Are Coefficients of Secular Equations in LCAO Evaluated?

In summary, the conversation discusses the calculation of coefficients in Linear Combination of Atomic Orbitals (LCAO) for a H2+ molecule-ion. The equations for obtaining the energies and coefficients are provided, as well as the condition for normalization. The question of whether to use the actual atomic number or the effective atomic number for a heteronuclear molecule is also brought up. It is clarified that the effective atomic number is only necessary for molecules with approximately single-electron atoms. The purpose of this discussion is to gain a better understanding of the LCAO method.
  • #1
sams
Gold Member
84
2
Moved from a technical forum, so homework template missing
Dear Everyone,

I would like to ask a question regarding the evaluation of the coefficients in Linear Combination of Atomic Orbitals (LCAO). In Molecular Quantum Mechanics book authored by Peter Atkins and Ronald Friedman (Fourth Edition ISBN 0199274983), we are trying to calculate the coefficients of the LCAO of H2+ (First atom: HA and Second atom: HB) molecule-ion.

After solving the 2x2 secular determinant of this system,
|α-E β-ES|
|β-ES α-E|
the energies are obtained as:
E+ = (α+β)/(1+S)
E- = (α-β)/(1-S)
Note: α and β are the expectation values of the Hamiltonian.

Solving the secular equations:
∑cr{Hrs - ESrs} = 0
We will obtain the real coefficients of the normalized wavefunctions:
cA = cB, ca = 1/{2(1+S)}½ for E+ = (α+β)/(1+S)
and
cA = -cB, ca = 1/{2(1-S)}½ for E- = (α-β)/(1-S)

1. I have proved that cA = cB and cA = -cB by matrix multiplication of the secular equations and inserting E+ and E- in the equations. But may anyone please advise me how can we obtain ca = 1/{2(1+S)}½ and ca = 1/{2(1-S)}½ ?

2. Another question regarding the overlap integral S in the above secular determinant. Solving this integral leads to the following relation: S = <A|B> = {1 + (ZR/ao) + 1/3(ZR/ao)2}e-ZR/ao
How can we calculate Z? Is it the Zeff for a compound or mixture found in the following link https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_atomic_number ?

Thanks a lot for the help and support...
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
sams said:
But may anyone please advise me how can we obtain ca = 1/{2(1+S)}½ and ca = 1/{2(1-S)}½ ?
Write down the condition for normalization.

sams said:
2. Another question regarding the overlap integral S in the above secular determinant. Solving this integral leads to the following relation: S = <A|B> = {1 + (ZR/ao) + 1/3(ZR/ao)2}e-ZR/ao
How can we calculate Z? Is it the Zeff for a compound or mixture found in the following link https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_atomic_number ?
Z is the actual atomic number, so Z=1 if you are considering H##_2^+##.
 
  • Like
Likes sams
  • #3
DrClaude said:
Write down the condition for normalization.

1. ∫Ψ*Ψ=1
∫(cAΦA + cBΦB)(cAΦA + cBΦB) = 1

Let: ∫ΦAΦB = ∫ΦBΦA = S
If: cA = cB then: cA = 1/{2(1+S)}½

DrClaude said:
Z is the actual atomic number, so Z=1 if you are considering H##_2^+##.

2. But in the case of heteronuclear diatomic molecule where we have different atomic numbers, shouldn't we calculate the Zeff of the compound as a whole as given in the link https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_atomic_number in second section "For a compound or mixture"?

Thank DrClaude for your advice.
 
  • #4
sams said:
2. But in the case of heteronuclear diatomic molecule where we have different atomic numbers, shouldn't we calculate the Zeff of the compound as a whole as given in the link https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_atomic_number in second section "For a compound or mixture"?
The secular equation you are using is valid for single-electron diatomic molecules. The equation for S given above is for a homonuclear diatomic molecule of hydrogenic atoms, such that wave functions ##\Phi_A## and ##\Phi_B## are identical except for their origin. For a heteronuclear molecule, you will have to recalculate that overlap integral.

An effective atomic number is only necessary if one of the atoms is only approximately a single-electron atom, such as an alkali atom.

What system do you want to apply this to, and what for?
 
  • Like
Likes sams
  • #5
There is no specific system I want to apply this. I just wanted to ask about the case of heteronuclear compounds. The idea is much clearer now. Thanks again DrClaude...
 

FAQ: How Are Coefficients of Secular Equations in LCAO Evaluated?

1. What are coefficients of secular equations?

Coefficients of secular equations are the numerical values that are used to represent the various terms in a secular equation. These coefficients are used to find the roots or solutions of a secular equation, which is a type of polynomial equation that involves a variable raised to a power.

2. How are coefficients of secular equations calculated?

The coefficients of secular equations are calculated using a variety of methods, such as the method of undetermined coefficients or the method of determinants. These methods involve manipulating the equations and solving for the coefficients using algebraic techniques.

3. What is the significance of coefficients of secular equations in scientific research?

Coefficients of secular equations are important in scientific research as they are used in a wide range of fields such as physics, chemistry, and engineering. They are used to model and analyze various physical phenomena and systems, and to make predictions about their behavior.

4. Can coefficients of secular equations be negative?

Yes, coefficients of secular equations can be negative. In fact, some equations may have both positive and negative coefficients, depending on the terms involved. These coefficients can represent different physical quantities, such as forces, energies, or rates of change.

5. How do coefficients of secular equations affect the solutions of the equation?

The coefficients of secular equations play a crucial role in determining the solutions or roots of the equation. They can affect the number of solutions, their values, and their stability. Changing the coefficients can also result in different types of solutions, such as real or complex roots.

Similar threads

Replies
13
Views
4K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
15
Views
2K
Back
Top