How can we reconcile the different vector dimensions in QM equations?

In summary, the conversation discusses the representation of spin up and spin down states, as well as the Hamiltonian and angular momentum operators in quantum mechanics. The conversation also addresses the challenge of satisfying equations with different dimensional vectors. It is suggested that an electron can be represented as a combination of a 2-dimensional vector and an infinite-dimensional vector, with the Hamiltonian acting on the infinite-dimensional vector and the angular momentum operator acting on the 2-dimensional vector.
  • #1
Bobhawke
144
0
In QM we require that an operator acting on a state vector gives the corresponding observable multiplied by the vector.

Spin up can be represented by the state vector [tex] \left( \begin{array}{c} 1 \\ 0 \end{array} \right) [/tex], while spin down can be represented by [tex] \left( \begin{array}{c} 0 \\ 1 \end{array} \right) [/tex]

As I understand the Hamiltonian is represented by an infinite dimensional matrix, because there is an infinite number of energy eigenstates. My question is, how can we satisfy both

[tex] \hat{H} \left | \psi \right \rangle = E \left | \psi \right \rangle [/tex]

and

[tex] \hat{L_{z}} \left | \psi \right \rangle = m\hbar \left | \psi \right \rangle[/tex]

when in one case [tex] \left | \psi \right \rangle [/tex] is a 2 dimensional vector, and in the other it is an infinite dimensional vector.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
different bits!

Bobhawke said:
My question is, how can we satisfy both

[tex] \hat{H} \left | \psi \right \rangle = E \left | \psi \right \rangle [/tex]

and

[tex] \hat{L_{z}} \left | \psi \right \rangle = m\hbar \left | \psi \right \rangle[/tex]

when in one case [tex] \left | \psi \right \rangle [/tex] is a 2 dimensional vector, and in the other it is an infinite dimensional vector.

Hi Bobhawke! :smile:

I think the answer is that an electron say could be

[tex]\left( \begin{array}{c} 1 \\ 0 \end{array} \right) \sum a_n\psi_n[/tex] ,

and the rank-two L acts on the left bit, while the infinite-rank H acts on the right bits. :smile:
 
  • #3
Ah of course I should have seen that.

Thanks tiny tim!
 

FAQ: How can we reconcile the different vector dimensions in QM equations?

What is a Hilbert space?

A Hilbert space is a mathematical concept in functional analysis that is used to study infinite-dimensional vector spaces. It is a complete vector space equipped with an inner product, which allows for the definition of distance and angles between vectors.

What are vectors in Hilbert space?

Vectors in Hilbert space are elements of the vector space that satisfy certain properties, such as being closed under addition and scalar multiplication. They can be represented by a list of coordinates or as functions, and they are used to model physical quantities in mathematics and physics.

What makes Hilbert space useful in science?

Hilbert space is useful in science because it provides a rigorous mathematical framework for studying infinite-dimensional vector spaces. It allows for the analysis of complex physical systems and the development of advanced mathematical models and techniques.

How are vectors in Hilbert space different from vectors in other vector spaces?

Unlike vectors in finite-dimensional vector spaces, vectors in Hilbert space have infinitely many components and can be represented as functions. Additionally, Hilbert space vectors have an inner product that allows for the definition of distance and angles between vectors.

What are some applications of Hilbert space in science?

Hilbert space has a wide range of applications in science, including quantum mechanics, signal processing, and control theory. It is also used in statistics, machine learning, and image and audio processing. Additionally, Hilbert space is used in the study of differential equations and partial differential equations.

Similar threads

Back
Top