How do real mathematicians learn enough

  • Thread starter metric tensor
  • Start date
In summary: If you want to be a great mathematician, you have to learn how to do that on your own.In summary, McKean was able to learn calculus and other advanced math concepts at a very young age due to his mother's background in mathematics. Itō was also able to learn advanced math concepts at a young age, but he did not receive the same "head start" as McKean.
  • #1
metric tensor
2
0
This post is inquiring about the process of how one obtains high level math knowledge .How does one produce papers such as this at 24-27 yrs old?

http://books.google.com/books?id=c8...&sa=X&ei=8qXkUZWxEeH9iwLx2YFQ&ved=0CGsQ6AEwCA

I remember taking calculus at 17 or so and reading some books on math but nothing, including my homework even approached anything like this. Is it just 5 years of constant study or do these people learn everything really fast while in HS and enter college with graduate level of knowledge?
How does one go about writing mathematics in this type of rigor? how does one make the jump from just fooling around to producing serious, PHD quality, respectable math like the example given? There seems to be a huge chasm between high-level math in papers versus what is contained in most college courses and textbooks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
One can learn a lot it 5-10 years. I don't know where your get 24-27 though McKean was it his thirties and Kiyoshi Itō was older than that. You are right that there is a significant difference. Both between an average and unusual student and between a given student and the same student after 10 years hard work.
 
  • #3
I'm not qualified to answer all of your questions, but I can share what I know. The kind of "head start" can make a difference. For example, the mathematician Manjul Bhargava finished his high school math courses by age 14 and his mother was also a mathematician. As a result, he conducted phenomenal research in his twenties. More info: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manjul_Bhargava.
 
  • #4
Most math courses are taught that math is something you do, such as solving problems. But math isn't just about that. It's a way of thinking, and this isn't normally taught. Mathematicians talk about it as a language. Only those who understand that language can use it to communicate. And I think that's where the problem is: most math teachers aren't mathematicians; they know how to teach students to solve problems but don't know how to teach math as a language. It's easy to take a math teacher licensing test and pass if you've taken a number of math courses but these tests don't require you to understand math as a language.
 
  • #5


I can tell you that becoming a mathematician is a long and rigorous process that requires dedication, hard work, and a passion for the subject. Real mathematicians do not just learn enough, they strive to continuously expand their knowledge and understanding of mathematics.

The process of becoming a mathematician typically starts in high school where students are introduced to basic mathematical concepts and skills. However, it is not just 5 years of constant study that leads to producing papers like the one mentioned in the post. Rather, it is a combination of years of study, practice, and research that leads to a deep understanding of mathematics.

Most mathematicians start their journey by pursuing a bachelor's degree in mathematics or a related field. During this time, they take advanced courses in various branches of mathematics and engage in research projects with their professors. This allows them to gain a solid foundation in mathematics and develop critical thinking and problem-solving skills.

After completing their undergraduate studies, many mathematicians pursue a graduate degree, typically a PhD, in a specific area of mathematics. This is where they dive deeper into their chosen field and conduct original research, often leading to the production of papers like the one mentioned in the post.

Writing mathematics in a rigorous and professional manner requires not only a deep understanding of the subject matter but also a thorough knowledge of mathematical language and notation. This is something that is developed over time through practice and exposure to high-level mathematical writing.

Overall, becoming a mathematician and producing high-quality, rigorous mathematics takes years of hard work, dedication, and a continuous pursuit of knowledge and understanding. There is no shortcut or easy way to achieve this level of expertise, but the journey is rewarding for those who have a true passion for mathematics.
 

FAQ: How do real mathematicians learn enough

How do real mathematicians approach learning?

Real mathematicians approach learning with a curious and analytical mindset. They are constantly seeking to understand the underlying principles and connections between different concepts, rather than just memorizing formulas or methods.

What study habits do mathematicians have?

Mathematicians often have a combination of discipline and creativity in their study habits. They regularly practice problems, take notes, and review material, but also allow themselves to think outside the box and explore different approaches to solving problems.

How do mathematicians stay motivated to learn difficult concepts?

Mathematicians are passionate about their subject and are driven by the desire to solve challenging problems and discover new ideas. They also understand that learning difficult concepts takes time and effort, and are patient with themselves in the process.

Do mathematicians have any tips for memorizing formulas and theorems?

While memorization is not the primary focus of mathematicians, they often find ways to make connections between different formulas and theorems to help with retention. They also rely on understanding the underlying principles and logic behind these concepts, rather than just memorizing them.

How do mathematicians learn to think abstractly?

Thinking abstractly is a skill that is developed over time through practice and exposure to a variety of mathematical concepts. Real mathematicians often start with concrete examples and then gradually move towards abstract thinking by generalizing and making connections between different ideas.

Similar threads

Replies
43
Views
6K
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
22
Views
5K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
19
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Back
Top