How Do Undergrad and Grad School Experiences Compare?

  • MHB
  • Thread starter Fantini
  • Start date
In summary, an undergraduate's experience with math may be better and easier than a graduate student's. However, the graduate student's experience with math may be much harder than an undergraduate's because of the sheer amount of homework and the lack of assistance.
  • #1
Fantini
Gold Member
MHB
268
0
How different have you perceived the two? Personally undergrad hasn't been any bed of roses for me. If people start to comment I'll give more details why, it has to do with a great overlap with graduate duties.

Do you feel things were better when you were an undergrad? Do (did) you prefer you graduate student time? Let's share experiences of a certainly turmoiled period.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Graduate math versus undergraduate math: tests about the same. Homework 5000 times harder. So in undergraduate, my homework-completion-strategy was simply the following:

1. Determine which homework set was due next.
2. Complete that homework set.
3. Repeat steps 1 and 2 for the entire semester.

That worked in undergraduate, where I could generally figure things out in a straight-forward manner. It didn't work in graduate school. What would happen is that I would sit and stare at a homework set for hours, getting nowhere. The best advice I ever got in graduate school was to change my algorithm to the following:

1. Start with one class's homework. Give it a good go. If you're on a roll, keep going.
2. As soon as you get good and stuck, STOP.
3. Move to the next class's homework, and repeat Steps 1 and 2.

In graduate school homework, it wasn't the sheer amount of time you threw at a homework set that got it done for you, it was the number of fresh starts. In addition, this approach allows inter-class pollination. An idea in one class might help in another.
 
  • #3
Thank you for your reply, Ackbach! I'm thoroughly familiar with this piece:

Ackbach said:
What would happen is that I would sit and stare at a homework set for hours, getting nowhere.
1. Start with one class's homework. Give it a good go. If you're on a roll, keep going.
2. As soon as you get good and stuck, STOP.
3. Move to the next class's homework, and repeat Steps 1 and 2.

But not the other. The explanation is simple: at my university, Mathematics majors are enrolled in almost all graduate subjects (all except 2, actually) during undergrad. In our fourth semester you are thrown into your first graduate course, and it keeps on a steady two subjects per semester after that (they recently altered slightly the order, leaving the sixth semester with three!), however you're not treated as an undergrad. In fact, some people don't even acknowledge the fact that part of the students aren't enrolled in PhDs yet.

The end result is we're treated like trash, facing odds tougher than our average level (quite tougher) without the due benefits. Honestly, memories of when I could do homework like your first algorithm are almost forgotten memories, tracing back to the three basic calculus courses.

Another small interesting piece of information, although not a complaint this time, is that mathematics major have no other contacts with different areas after you finish the basic three semesters. That means you get to do basic physics up to electromagnetism, and that's it.

I find it sad that we get to miss some of the more interesting (mathematically and physically) advanced subjects, such as Analytical Mechanics, Quantum Mechanics, General Relativity, Electromagnetism (done right) and several others.
 
  • #4
Fantini said:
I find it sad that we get to miss some of the more interesting (mathematically and physically) advanced subjects, such as Analytical Mechanics, Quantum Mechanics, General Relativity, Electromagnetism (done right) and several others.

All of those subjects should be offered as part of a maths course (though you should never encounter them first, if you can avoid it, from the maths department since they are taught devoid of their meaning)

CB
 
  • #5
CaptainBlack said:
All of those subjects should be offered as part of a maths course (though you should never encounter them first, if you can avoid it, from the maths department since they are taught devoid of their meaning)

CB
I agree with you entirely, I feel like I'm missing a great deal in my undergraduation not having exposure to these topics from the physics department. Have you seen Spivak's new book, Physics for Mathematicians: Mechanics 1? This might be one book right on the spot. Apparently it grew out of some lecture notes for elementary physics courses. He said he always wanted to learn physics and decided to create the series as a way to do that.

There's this quote from the Lecture 1 that I find amusing and true:
Spivak said:
So then people would say, Ah, so you're going to be writing about symplecticstructures, or something of that sort. And I would have to say, No, I'm not trying to write a book about mathematics for mathematicians, I'm trying to write a book about physics for mathematicians; of course, symplectic structures will eventually make an appearance, but the problem is that I could easily understand symplectic structures, it's elementary mechanics that I don't understand.
 

FAQ: How Do Undergrad and Grad School Experiences Compare?

What is the difference between undergraduation and graduation?

Undergraduation refers to the period of academic study before a student receives a bachelor's degree. Graduation, on the other hand, is the ceremony in which a student officially receives their degree and completes their undergraduate education.

What are the requirements for undergraduation?

The specific requirements for undergraduation vary depending on the institution and degree program. However, in general, students must complete a certain number of credits, maintain a minimum GPA, and fulfill any major or general education requirements in order to graduate.

How long does it take to complete undergraduation?

The length of time it takes to complete undergraduation also varies depending on the degree program and individual circumstances. On average, it takes about four years of full-time study to complete a bachelor's degree.

What is the difference between an undergraduate and a graduate degree?

An undergraduate degree (such as a bachelor's degree) is typically the first level of higher education and focuses on general education and foundational knowledge in a specific field. A graduate degree (such as a master's or doctoral degree) is a higher level of education that builds upon the knowledge and skills gained during undergraduate studies and often leads to more specialized career opportunities.

What is the significance of graduating with honors?

Graduating with honors typically means that a student has achieved a high level of academic performance during their undergraduate studies. This may be based on their GPA, completion of an honors program, or other criteria set by the institution. Graduating with honors can be a distinction on a student's resume and may open up opportunities for scholarships, graduate programs, or job opportunities.

Similar threads

Replies
17
Views
4K
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
82
Views
5K
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
14
Views
807
Replies
14
Views
4K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Back
Top