How Does Burnside's Lemma Calculate the Number of Distinct Colored Cubes?

  • MHB
  • Thread starter mathjam0990
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Application
In summary, this equation tells you how many fixed points there are of a certain shape in a certain configuration space.
  • #1
mathjam0990
29
0
Q: How many different colored cubes are there in which each face is colored either red or white or blue?

I know we have to use Burnside's Lemma to solve this. (1/|G|)* Σ f(g) where f(g) are the number of fixed points of g. I also know that one of the values will be 3^6, but that is where I get stuck. Can someone please give an explanation as to how to find the rest of the equation? Thank you!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The first thing you need to do is figure out what "$G$" is (in this case, it is $S_4$), and then figure out what $X$ is (the set that $G$ is acting upon). In this case it is the configuration space of all $3^6$ possible colorings of the cube, where we keep track of which face got which color (some of these we would not be able to tell apart under a physical rotation in the real world).

Indeed the number of fixed points of the identity is $3^6$, since every face remains unchanged.

Suppose we rotate about the line between the mid-point of the top face and the mid-point of the bottom face, say by 90 degrees. We can then ask: how may fixed points does this have?

Well, the only way this can happen is if the rotated faces (there are 4 of these) are all the same color, all red, or all white, or all blue. For each of these 3 possibilities, we are free to chose the top and bottom faces any way we choose. Since we have $3^2$ choices for top and bottom faces, this gives $3^3$ fixed points of $X$ for this rotation.

The same is true for any such rotation about two opposite faces. We have six such rotations, so a second term is:

$6\cdot 3^3$.

Your task, now, is to investigate the other three types of rotations (a 180 degree face rotation, about a vertex (120 degrees), and about two opposite edges (180 degrees)).
 

FAQ: How Does Burnside's Lemma Calculate the Number of Distinct Colored Cubes?

What is Burnside's Lemma?

Burnside's Lemma is a mathematical theorem that provides a method for counting the number of distinct orbits under a group action. It is often used in combinatorics and group theory to solve problems involving symmetry.

How is Burnside's Lemma applied?

Burnside's Lemma is applied by considering the symmetries of an object or group and using them to simplify the counting process. It involves breaking down the group action into smaller, more manageable subgroups and then calculating the number of orbits for each subgroup. The final result is then obtained by taking the average of these subgroup counts.

What are some common applications of Burnside's Lemma?

Burnside's Lemma has many applications in combinatorics, group theory, and other areas of mathematics. Some common examples include counting the number of distinct necklaces, bracelets, and colorings of objects with rotational symmetries. It can also be used to solve problems involving graph theory and polyhedra.

What are the limitations of Burnside's Lemma?

Burnside's Lemma can only be applied to problems involving finite groups and objects with finite symmetries. It also assumes that the group action is transitive, meaning that every object can be transformed into any other object through the group's symmetries. In addition, it may not always provide an exact solution and may require additional calculations or approximations.

Are there any alternative methods to Burnside's Lemma for counting orbits?

Yes, there are other methods for counting orbits, such as the Pólya Enumeration Theorem and the Cycle Index Polynomial. These methods may be more efficient in certain cases, but Burnside's Lemma is often preferred for its simplicity and intuitive approach.

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
33
Views
8K
Replies
9
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top