How Sensitive Must SETI Arrays Be to Detect Extraterrestrial Signals?

  • B
  • Thread starter Canada Bob
  • Start date
In summary, the possibility of a signal from advanced ET's being picked up by SETI arrays is low due to the sensitivity of the receivers and the power needed to transmit a signal. It is possible to transmit a powerful signal if it is aimed specifically at the SETI arrays, but this is unlikely to happen.
  • #1
Canada Bob
20
2
TL;DR Summary
SETI
Fermi asks "why don't we hear from them" could that be because they don't "shout" loud enough or maybe our ears are sensitive enough to pick up a signal emitted by advanced ET's within just our own backyard.

Is it down to the sensitivity of the SETI arrays, or the strength of a signal from within our own galaxy to be picked up by the SETI or any other array on Earth ?

How "loud" would a signal have to be to travel from the further reaches of our own galaxy to be picked up by SETI, how much power would that transmission need ? is it possible to transmit such a powerful signal ?

Yea, I know, it's 6 of one and half a dozen of the other, hopefully there's an overlap as to how strong a signal could be and how sensitive a receiver could be ?

Bob.
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
  • #2
Canada Bob said:
Summary:: SETI

How "loud" would a signal have to be to travel from the further reaches of our own galaxy to be picked up by SETI, how much power would that transmission need ? is it possible to transmit such a powerful signal ?
That's not answerable without knowing how directional and focused the signal is. Think of an old fashioned lighthouse with only a flame as a light source. Ships 20 or more miles out to sea can see the flash of light.

But even with a highly focused beam, I think the only chance is from nearby stars.
 
  • Like
Likes FactChecker
  • #3
IIRC, this is why there's now efforts to search for laser-borne signals.

One 'gotcha' on collimation etc is to use system star as Einsteinian lens.
IIRC, our 'focus' at ~550 AU, ~3 light-days, would give 'a few metres' resolution imaging of stars and planets out to 50-some light-years, 'kilometres' to thrice that.

Snag is each target system would probably need its own observatory and out-riders.

Conversely, the same 'lensing' could be used to practicably transmit towards those systems without requiring 'absurd' beam energies...

Down-side is improbability of intercepting such unless aimed our way...

Could be said that getting out to 'focus' represents a major 'filter'...
 
  • #4
According to Seth Shostak, SETI searches aren't really looking for radio: they are looking for radar, presumably as part of a meteor early warning system. There is incentive to make the beam as powerful as you can and as directional as you can ( @anorlunda's point).
 

FAQ: How Sensitive Must SETI Arrays Be to Detect Extraterrestrial Signals?

Why do some animals have bigger ears than others?

The size of an animal's ears is often related to their habitat and lifestyle. Animals that live in open areas or hunt at night tend to have larger ears to help them hear and locate prey. On the other hand, animals that live in dense forests may have smaller ears to avoid getting caught on branches.

Can bigger ears hear louder noises?

Yes, bigger ears can generally hear louder noises because they have a larger surface area to capture sound waves. However, the sensitivity of an animal's ears also plays a role in how well they can hear loud noises.

Do larger ears provide better hearing?

Not necessarily. The size of an animal's ears is just one factor that contributes to their hearing abilities. Other factors such as the shape and structure of the ear, as well as the animal's brain and auditory system, also play important roles in their hearing abilities.

Are there any disadvantages to having bigger ears?

Having bigger ears can make an animal more vulnerable to predators, as they may be easier to spot in their environment. Additionally, larger ears can also be more prone to injury or infection if not properly cared for.

Can an animal's ears get too big?

Yes, an animal's ears can become too big for their body, which can affect their balance and coordination. This is why most animals have ears that are proportionate to their body size and weight.

Similar threads

B Could neutrinos be the key to successful SETI communication?
Replies
2
Views
1K
B How good are our ears? (Detectable Interstellar signals)
Replies
7
Views
1K
I How Far Can the Square Kilometre Array 'Listen' for Extraterrestrial Signals?
Replies
22
Views
2K
Question About the Wow Signal from 1977
Replies
10
Views
10K
B Gravitational Wave System and Locations
Replies
2
Views
1K
What Has SETI Ruled Out in the Search for Alien Civilizations?
2
Replies
38
Views
13K
SETI: What would it take to monitor all probable bands.
Replies
4
Views
3K
Cellular phones and reverse SETI
Replies
9
Views
3K
Detecting transmission signal destinations
Replies
12
Views
3K
Cell Phone Tower Communication: How Does it Work?
Replies
1
Views
2K

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top